Marshy - Should he stay or should he go?

[NW_Hoopz]

This wasn't anti scottish .......i was hoping he was scottish !!!!!!

found this one for ya

[acricketer]

Things must be slow. Is this a QPR thread and is the rightful place in this part of the forum?

[QPRDave]

We were just demonstrating how easy it is to hijack threads........that damn marshy!!!!!!

[NW_Hoopz]

Things must be slow. Is this a QPR thread and is the rightful place in this part of the forum?

And I was just complaining about the anti Scottish BULLYING that was taking place ................... Sorry

[QPR71]

But I usually post in my own threads. How can I be hijacking someone's thread then?

Most of the 57 aren't well respected, most of them are lackeys, who don't like it when someone goes against their view. If you criticise Harry, no matter how reasonable your criticism is, they will start calling you clueless, and not being true fans of the club. It is only when things start going bad do they then start to criticise the manager, and then act as if they knew all along the manager was not suitable.

Case in point: Mark Hughes. Go and read my opinion on him. I stated he is not a good manager, that he is not the right one for us, that he was mediocre at Fulham, yet there were people arguing with me that he is a proven good manager. Now those very people say MH was sh1te.

I don't believe in knee-jerk nonsense, or forming opinions just because Shearer or some other ***** said so. I like to analyse all the facts, and then come to my own conclusions.

I would like to be able to continue posting, as this is a very special season, and the club is in a very interesting point in it's history. It is important that we have people like me who give thoughtful insight on the current situation of the club and where it is heading, because there are not many people here who think for themselves, and so there is the danger that the club could head in the wrong direction and it is too late before people realise. But it seems as if you will let the poll decide my fate, and I am sorry, it IS mob justice. It is a few bullies that have stirred up an atmosphere of hate that has influenced normal people to join in and want me banned. The whole tenet of freedom of speech is that people with opinions that are unpopular should be allowed to express them. I mean, no one in a democratic society wants to ban popular opinions, it is always the unpopular opinions that they want banned. And that is why freedom of speech exists, because sometimes, opinions that might be unpopular, might not be so because they're "wrong", but because they're opinions that don't make people feel good about themselves. No one wants to hear bad things being said about their clubs, but let me tell you this - if Leeds or Pompey or Glasgow Rangers fans had sat up and criticised their clubs, they would not be in the sorry situation where they are today.

it is this sort of ridiculous pathological arrogance that annoys people
also you imply that you are of special importance as only you can see where we are going wrong like everyone else lives somewhere over the rainbow and thinks everything qpr is hunky dory.
yet ive seen all kinds of posters naming various players as sh1t, tactics as sh1t, board TF etc. weve just been through a whole positive v negatives phase which got heated and
these views were about various issues and polar opposites. so your sheep accusation doesnt hold

some of your views i agree with others i dont. none are unknown secrets. im guessing the same ratio agree/disagree, have thought about or posted/debated about any point you have made.
(mackie at DM aside). you are not special Marshy, drop the omnipitent knowledge act and youll do ok here. also re bullying, its not PM'd so its time you specified what it is.
put up or shut up

[gaza09]

It's called autism leave him to it

[gator]

it is this sort of ridiculous pathological arrogance that annoys people
also you imply that you are of special importance as only you can see where we are going wrong like everyone else lives somewhere over the rainbow and thinks everything qpr is hunky dory.
yet ive seen all kinds of posters naming various players as sh1t, tactics as sh1t, board TF etc. weve just been through a whole positive v negatives phase which got heated and
these views were about various issues and polar opposites. so your sheep accusation doesnt hold

some of your views i agree with others i dont. none are unknown secrets. im guessing the same ratio agree/disagree, have thought about or posted/debated about any point you have made.
(mackie at DM aside). you are not special Marshy, drop the omnipitent knowledge act and youll do ok here. also re bullying, its not PM'd so its time you specified what it is.
put up or shut up

I agree with you but no matter how much I read about why he should be banned it doesn't seem right the dude should go because people don't agree with him or think he fancies himself as a know it all!

[Buffalo]

I agree with you but no matter how much I read about why he should be banned it doesn't seem right the dude should go because people don't agree with him or think he fancies himself as a know it all!

I agree with that. I don't think those are good reasons on their own. However, a good portion of this forum these days seems to go off topic and turn into threats and insults just because of Marshy. That spoils a lot of threads for me and is far from the good debate that others claim that he provokes. As I said earlier, it's not necessarily that he deserves it every time, but he has upset enough people here now that they automatically react in a negative way to him. Add to that the way he has just insulted almost everybody on here and that makes me think he should go. I would rather he stayed and stopped provoking the reactions that he does but the mods have tried addressing that privately and it hasn't worked.

[silvercue]

Seriously - can we just close this retarded thread now?

The guy stays if he doesn't break the rules. Anything else will make the site a laughing stock.

And please don't say "don't read this thread if you don't like it".....there is nothing else to read as you are all in here !!

Anyway, I said my bit about 125 pages ago.

[Ginger Ninja]

It's called autism leave him to it

i like a laugh and a giggle but that just aint something to joke about.

[qprted]

look

look its simple but true
marshy we hate you
you have a chelskie tattoo

are you having a lark
you claim to be born at griffin park

theres enough insannity on this forum already
with me and facto eh steady eddie
marshy stay in bed and cuddle your teddy

the dot orgs the place for you to post
its really enjoyable whilst your eating toast
sign up as marshies ghost

[madara]

I agree with that. I don't think those are good reasons on their own. However, a good portion of this forum these days seems to go off topic and turn into threats and insults just because of Marshy. That spoils a lot of threads for me and is far from the good debate that others claim that he provokes. As I said earlier, it's not necessarily that he deserves it every time, but he has upset enough people here now that they automatically react in a negative way to him. Add to that the way he has just insulted almost everybody on here and that makes me think he should go. I would rather he stayed and stopped provoking the reactions that he does but the mods have tried addressing that privately and it hasn't worked.

people get upset and post sh1t because of marshys opinions so he should get banned...

Seriously?

[madara]

bully

a blustering, quarrelsome, overbearing person who habitually badgers and intimidates smaller or weaker people.


To me it seems some of you guys repeatedly do this to people who has a completely different opinion than yours. Why is not the infaraction point system working? Because it seems to me it is only followed selectively.

Post nr 276 and 281 are to me insulting and therefore bullying if the same person does it repeatedly.

[vblockranger]

bully

a blustering, quarrelsome, overbearing person who habitually badgers and intimidates smaller or weaker people.


To me it seems some of you guys repeatedly do this to people who has a completely different opinion than yours. Why is not the infaraction point system working? Because it seems to me it is only followed selectively.

Post nr 276 and 281 are to me insulting and therefore bullying if the same person does it repeatedly.

leave it out

[qprted]

so

so marshy hates rangers so much that he has to come on here and spout off a load of nasty rubbish if he is mad he should still be banned because there are message boards full of idiots let him join them