Harry Redknapp

[Stanley]

what has he done for QPR

Got a team that had 3/4 points in 13 games to pick up 13/14 points in the same amount of games

We are rock bottom 7pts from safety

That doesn't make Dave's point any less valid, superhoop67.

[superhoop67]

That doesn't make Dave's point any less valid, superhoop67.

hardly makes our position any better either ,still keep doing those arithmetic equations

[WeAreQPR12]

That doesn't make Dave's point any less valid, superhoop67.

Stanley you're wrong with Dangerous Dave!

Superhoop67 is clearly stating that our league position states no improvement.

We're bottom of the league with a 7pt gap. Yes fixtures do get a little easier after united but it's the easier games we tend to play negative in. We love sitting back and catching a side out which is fine against top 4 but lets hope and pray things change!

[Stanley]

Stanley you're wrong with Dangerous Dave!

Superhoop67 is clearly stating that our league position states no improvement.

Youre right about our league position WeAre, but the point Dave's making is our form since Harry took over has improved (bar the Swansea game) and that is the scrap of hope we have no choice but to cling on to - the optimists amongst us at least Remy is back from injury now too, as is Hoilett, so we also have to hope those two and Samba find the form to give us a fighting chance of survival.

[QPRDave]

Stanley you're wrong with Dangerous Dave!

Superhoop67 is clearly stating that our league position states no improvement.

We're bottom of the league with a 7pt gap. Yes fixtures do get a little easier after united but it's the easier games we tend to play negative in. We love sitting back and catching a side out which is fine against top 4 but lets hope and pray things change!

.....not as dangerous as me bruvver!!!

[qprted]

its

its a bit like saying how did neil warnock bring us up with one of the worst promotion sides in the history of football

people like warnock and arry boy redknapp can make players believe in them selves this thread is completely destructive its certainly not going to do the players any good

its certainly not going to do redknapp any good

it certainly wont help us to stay up

what does the creator of this thread want us to do then sack redknapp and install a new manager

next season if we drop i think we will lose arry boy and i will be sad,because hes a great manager
in every sense of the word

[qblockoompah]

No cop out its the truth.

He might be a big name but that doesn't necessarily mean he is the right man for the job

Never said he's the right man for the job, just definitely the "biggest name" we could get. I didn't want us to appoint HR and I got slaughtered for it.

But I do love him and I think we're doing ok

[Shepherds Mush]

Why have a go at Harry ? He masterminded a win at Chelsea which we will NEVER forget !!

[W12_Ranger]

Why have a go at Harry ? He masterminded a win at Chelsea which we will NEVER forget !!

That sort of statement I find embarrassing, real small club mentality

[qpr4life]

That sort of statement I find embarrassing, real small club mentality

Are we a big club though...

People forget where we are and who we are these days.

Stadium - 18K Cap...
Players - Still many average players
Small academy - Cannot create our own world class players etc

The list could go on

[superhoop67]

Are we a big club though...

People forget where we are and who we are these days.

Stadium - 18K Cap...
Players - Still many average players
Small academy - Cannot create our own world class players etc

The list could go on

so why do people talk about 40,000 seat stadia

[zeberdee]

Don't post in these these threads usually because most of this Redknapp debate is pointless imo.
He don't score goals or save goals it is the players that do that and he has to work with what he has.

TBH if QPR stay up a lot of the credit goes to Mark Hughes. Because Harry is almost entirely working mostly with what he bought.
If Harry gets them to a top6/survival run of form in the last 10 games then he has performed a miracle of tactics and motivation.

But Hughes bought most of them and if they can play like a top6 side you got to wonder why they refused to do this for MH and at least half of this season too even with Harry in charge.

[stanistheman]

I don't think Redknapp is a great manager by any stretch of the imagination, but he is a decent one, and deserves credit for his work at West Ham, Portsmouth and Tottenham. Only one trophy won but he has usually achieved top 8 finishes or saved teams from the drop.

Having said that his work at QPR so far leaves very little to be happy with.


I think he has set the side out in a very negative manner in most of his games.

At times he hasn't had many options, but in some games where he has chosen Mackie as a lone central striker, I think he has been wrong.
Had QPR played against the likes of Villa Wigan,West Ham Norwich & Swansea with 2 strikers QPR might have go more points than they did.

I would also have played Bothroyd alongside Remy at West Ham and Man City rather than Mackie on the right wing.

Redknapp still has some time to turn things around...but not much.

[maddix]

Don't post in these these threads usually because most of this Redknapp debate is pointless imo.
He don't score goals or save goals it is the players that do that and he has to work with what he has.

TBH if QPR stay up a lot of the credit goes to Mark Hughes. Because Harry is almost entirely working mostly with what he bought.
If Harry gets them to a top6/survival run of form in the last 10 games then he has performed a miracle of tactics and motivation.

But Hughes bought most of them and if they can play like a top6 side you got to wonder why they refused to do this for MH and at least half of this season too even with Harry in charge.

Surely a contradiction of words here ....And as for giving ANY credit to Hughes for ANY aspects of this season are f ucking laughable !!!!

[W12_Ranger]

Are we a big club though...

People forget where we are and who we are these days.

Stadium - 18K Cap...
Players - Still many average players
Small academy - Cannot create our own world class players etc

The list could go on

I don't need to be educated I know exactly who we are, read my signature. I'm not som tourist to the manor who dreams of nice big shiny new stadium. But if you think I'm gonna be making stupid statements about doing Chelsea you must be joking , you clearly don't know enough old school Chelsea fans...they are slaughtering us at present.