Geordies want phillips

[Harryboy]

IMO we should snap there hands off for matty, not consistent enough does to much flash stuff and then loses the ball, if we can get our money back on him I think it was 4mill we should let him go as he's got 18 months to go on his contract, if we get more than 4mill then that's a bonus

[West Acton]

There desperate so should get £8mil in today's market

[WeAreQPR12]

IMO we should snap there hands off for matty, not consistent enough does to much flash stuff and then loses the ball, if we can get our money back on him I think it was 4mill we should let him go as he's got 18 months to go on his contract, if we get more than 4mill then that's a bonus

You make some very fair pts hazza but I think I am going to have to stop you there. He certainly has been underperforming but his main asset is his delivery. He is clearly a fish out of water having to play the lone striker and he is highlighting the players we should make a priority of getting rid of in seb polter. Yes we won't get anything for him but yet another player earning free money with nothing in return. Phillips is a right winger and he needs 5 or 6 games played in this position. I just hope and pray Charlie stays fit because Matty's game is all about having Austin in the box. Let's not forget all have a fresh start and I hope to see a few key players upping their game so hold fire hazza IMO with your opinion.

[brightonr]

Possibly worth waiting to see what effect a competent manager has on his game, both individually and within the team.

[dave58]

There desperate so should get £8mil in today's market

Exactly if they're desperate for him let them pay shouldn't take less than £7m

[Quaz]

You make some very fair pts hazza but I think I am going to have to stop you there. He certainly has been underperforming but his main asset is his delivery. He is clearly a fish out of water having to play the lone striker and he is highlighting the players we should make a priority of getting rid of in seb polter. Yes we won't get anything for him but yet another player earning free money with nothing in return. Phillips is a right winger and he needs 5 or 6 games played in this position. I just hope and pray Charlie stays fit because Matty's game is all about having Austin in the box. Let's not forget all have a fresh start and I hope to see a few key players upping their game so hold fire hazza IMO with your opinion.

This, nail on the head

[Shania]

Why sell a player who is clearly played out of position? With the right support he is a prem winger. A must keep in my opinion. A player JFH would love to have in his Squad, I think.

[geejaybee]

Phillips v Townsend

http://news.bwin.com/en/football-betting/premier-league/qpr-star-a-far-superior-choice-to-spurs-outcast-in-newcastle-winger-hunt,93510.html

[Harryboy]

You make some very fair pts hazza but I think I am going to have to stop you there. He certainly has been underperforming but his main asset is his delivery. He is clearly a fish out of water having to play the lone striker and he is highlighting the players we should make a priority of getting rid of in seb polter. Yes we won't get anything for him but yet another player earning free money with nothing in return. Phillips is a right winger and he needs 5 or 6 games played in this position. I just hope and pray Charlie stays fit because Matty's game is all about having Austin in the box. Let's not forget all have a fresh start and I hope to see a few key players upping their game so hold fire hazza IMO with your opinion.

fair point mate

[ArthurQPR_NYC]

lets see how JFH handles this surplus of midfielders before we lose the plot. if he can't find a place for luongo philips fer chery and hoilett, then and only then should we talk about selling

[nasser95]

lets see how JFH handles this surplus of midfielders before we lose the plot. if he can't find a place for luongo philips fer chery and hoilett, then and only then should we talk about selling

I don't even think that is possible without rotation is it? Unless Luongo is converted to some full back role. Also bear in mind the existence of Faurlin and Sandro. Having a squad with these guys available is what makes us such a good prospect and why I think we can get promoted. Selling because we can't get them all in at once goes against the project IMO.

[FACTS]

Should be looking for 7M as an absolute minimum. Given our track record with signings we might struggle to replace him for anything less, I'd rather hold on to him than get bumped by Spurs again for Andros. I'd hold on to Philips..

If we look abroad we can easily replace him though, I'm hoping JFH gets the freedom to pick out a few players from the Dutch/Belgian leagues rather than leaving it all to Les.

[surrey_hoop]

We should've accepted the interest from WBA last season. 1 decent game every 5 (at best) doesn't equate to an £8million player in my opinion. As Harryboy has already alluded to, we'll look to get back what we paid for him and cut our losses. He was a gamble worth taking, but he simply hasn't improved to anything like the level many thought he would achieve. Playing on such a narrow pitch at LR doesn't help wingers either.

[Garyd73]

Sell him if we get offered £5m or more and he wants to go and buy a striker.

[AberdeenR]

Philips gives his all every game and is our best attacking player in my opinion, we shouldn't be in a rush to get rid of him