Mackie

[SammyKojoe]

Just not good enough. He creates nothing, slows the play down and does not have the ability to beat a man. He can however run into him. Time for Holiett to get a run of games and see if he can give Cisse some decent service.

[Shania]

Mackie and Cisse = personality clash, I feel.

[Ric-Roc]

Kisses the badge & gets crowd to up the volume so should start every game.











Apparently.

[SuperHoopNik]

And then when he scores next week, there will be threads praising him. And when he doesn't score the week after there will be threads like this....

It doesn't end lol. He isn't a natural winger, he's a striker but he does OK for a winger. In fact he got loads of assists and 8 goals playing that position last season. He is good enough, and has proved it MANY times.

[superhoop67]

if there wasn't a fence round the Loftus Rd pitch Mackie would be half way down the Bayswater Rd now

[West Acton]

if there wasn't a fence round the Loftus Rd pitch Mackie would be half way down the Bayswater Rd now

I think he should play up top and up top alone as he works the centre backs and does not let them settle. Does not offer enough on the wing other then hussle and bussle

[thefatgod1]

Great heart and work rate. Poor player limited ability.
Such a pity others don't have his passion or he their talent

[SammyKojoe]

And then when he scores next week, there will be threads praising him. And when he doesn't score the week after there will be threads like this....

It doesn't end lol. He isn't a natural winger, he's a striker but he does OK for a winger. In fact he got loads of assists and 8 goals playing that position last season. He is good enough, and has proved it MANY times.

That is wrong for starters. SWP got our most assists last season with 6 so not sure how Mackie got "loads"

I don't fault his effort or his passion. But he really is not good enough. Hoilett came on and beat a defender and put a decent cross in 3 times in the last 5 minutes. That is more than Mackie did all game.

[QPR1234]

please tell me who you'd play ahead of him? so many wasters in our squad its really difficult to not pick mackie. personally id have mackie up front every game ahead of cisse. fact is either cisse or mackie up front = no real goal return.

our strongest area midfield has so many underperformers.. hoilett, swp, granero.. even taarabt to an extent. all we can hope for is players like hill, mackie, nelson who gives two ****s about their performance and the teams position in the league.

hard work over 'potentially' gifted players.

[qpr]

I still think players that are working hard are needed, he's clearly a player that divides opinions

[Marshy]

I think there were a lot worse players than Mackie today.

[Ric-Roc]

Defo worse than him but I would have Hoilett over him every single time personally.

[MattyRangers]

Defo worse than him but I would have Hoilett over him every single time personally.

Snap . Hoilet is a quality player we need to give him games not chuck him on for the odd 10 mins here n there n let the whingers spout how he's done nothing.

[qblockoompah]

I think Hoillet has been absolutely shocking IMO. Looks fat and lazy when he comes on. Against villa when he came on he was a disgrace. No doubt he has the ability, but for some reason he isn't showing it or even trying to. Although I wasn't there today so can't comment

[paulmason]

Just not good enough. He creates nothing, slows the play down and does not have the ability to beat a man. He can however run into him. Time for Holiett to get a run of games and see if he can give Cisse some decent service.

On todays performance, who are you talking about Adel or Jamie, or is it only Jamie who is not alowed to play badly but Adel can do what he wants ?