James Collins signs for West Ham

[W12hoops]

Good signing. We should have tried signing him up.

[Fordy]

Good signing. We should have tried signing him up.

Hes ok. Wouldn't be fussed either way if he came to us. Wouldn't mind getting that Caulker on a season long loan.

[MattyRangers]

Caulker is top drawer, will be England CB in a few years. Think he will get a few games with Spuds this year though, what with King gone and Dawson being a sick note, him & Kaboul could make a tidy little partnership.

[twranger]

Why is it when certain players, who have never ever been mentioned as a QPR target, sign for another club, there's always some who think we should have gone for him!
Same happened when Snodgrass signed for Norwich. Very odd!

[MattyRangers]

In all honesty I would not have been impressed 1 bit if we signed Snodgrass. Nowhere near as good as Hoilett, Tarbs, Park, Mackie or Traore IMHO.

[qpr]

Why is it when certain players, who have never ever been mentioned as a QPR target, sign for another club, there's always some who think we should have gone for him!
Same happened when Snodgrass signed for Norwich. Very odd!

Exactly, and I don't think too highly off him ( he's no more then a 15-20 league position player )

[EYR]

WHU are more than welcome to Max Branning,im sure with him and George McCartney back for 13th time they will be fine,oh and lets not forget Tevez and Carroll

[qpr]

WHU are more than welcome to Max Branning,im sure with him and George McCartney back for 13th time they will be fine,oh and lets not forget Tevez and Carroll

I thought we've already signed Andy Johnson

[QPRDave]

Hes ok. Wouldn't be fussed either way if he came to us. Wouldn't mind getting that Caulker on a season long loan.

Would be good signing agree

[Deadend_Friend]

Really? I think he's a poor defender. Only really good at hoofing the ball forward

[Tarbie]

Really? I think he's a poor defender. Only really good at hoofing the ball forward

Agreed, I'm sure we will bring in a higher calibre of centre half than Collins before the window shuts.

[qpr]

Really? I think he's a poor defender. Only really good at hoofing the ball forward

Agreed, that's why I said 15th to 20th PL player... which will be handy for West Ham

[qblockoompah]

Anton , Hill and Nelsen all better IMO

[QPRDave]

Really? I think he's a poor defender. Only really good at hoofing the ball forward

I was talking about Caulker

[W12hoops]

I believe he would have formed a great partnership with Anton. I guess we're setting our sights higher then..