Carroll to QPR?

[Connell10]

would you want him at rangers on a season long loan?yes or no.

[Norths]

Would he get ahead of Zamora and Cisse?

[DeepcutHoop]

would you want him at rangers on a season long loan?yes or no.

Yes absolutely. Like a shot.

[Connell10]

thats not a yes or no is it!

[Del]

No

[Norths]

thats not a yes or no is it!

Sorry boss

[RblockTourist]

If we didnt have so many strikers on the books then yes

[Connell10]

Sorry boss

thats ok just dont do it again!

[QPRDave]

Would he get ahead of Zamora and Cisse?

nah not for me he wouldn't we have better players in them 2

[Ginger Ninja]

Yes I would. Better than Zamora in my opinion, and I like Zamora.

[W12_Ranger]

unplayable on his day IMO

I really rate Andy Carroll very highly, i heard a story last summer about him and what last season's performances were going to end up like below par and they did. It was well-publicised when he first signed for Liverpool he was on the beer all the time and when the fitness coaches done an assessment of him during pre-season last year they estimated it would take him a whole season to get up to the required fitness levels once again for the Premier league. Based on that information and seeing how he can grew towards the end of the season I believe that speculation about him may have not been too far wide of the truth. I believe next season he will be well and truly amongst the goals and will come good in my opinion.

[Connell10]

i would take him on loan, i think at the end of last season and to a lesser extent playing for england he looked very good! i think he has promise but needs to knuckle down and really work on his game! oh and gets his girly barnet cut!

[Gtleighsr3]

yep and he must be pissed off now so have a massive point to prove

[Connell10]

Yes I would. Better than Zamora in my opinion, and I like Zamora.

i always check your posts ginger to see who has come in and who has gone!

[Bigears]

I wouldnt but not because he isnt good enough as I think he can be a great player and as already said can be unplayable onhis day. But why should we be the ones to teach him and bring him on to the next level as TF said we are nobodies second team.

If they agree a transfer fee and a clause to perchase if he proves himself that Liverpool / Carrol couldnt get out of, then now thatsa different story.