Best defender last 20 years

[QPROslo]

According West London Sport, Kevin Gallen thinks Rob Dickie is the best defender we have had during the last twenty years. Thats a big testimonial!

During these years we have had a fee very decent defenders, including Danny Maddix, Richard Dunne, Rio Ferdinand, Danny Shittu, Clarke Carlisle, Matthew Conolly, Kaspar Gorkks, Fitz Hall, Damion Stewart, Nedum Onuoha, Clint Hill, Danny Simpson and Jack Robinson to mention a few.

If Dickie is better than all of these he is worth a lot already.

To me, Maddix is the best of that bunch. I would be delighted if Dickie turns out even better than Maddix.

[Jeffqpr]

Maddox was also very good at man marking a player out of the game

[cross it Dave]

Ryan Nelsen would be on my list.

[Banbury]

Agree bout Nelson.....for me Maddix & Clint....

[northampton rs]

Chris Samba , to add to the list.

[hoopsmanjake]

Karl ready ?? Ill get my coat

[MYU]

Danny Maddix is one of my all-time favourite players at QPR.

I'm not sure about Rob Dickie yet.

[hillsy1302]

+1 for Maddix. As good as the others were, his Rangers side played at the highest level of them all.

[Stainrod]

Have we all forgot Steven Caulker ?

[Undecided]

Have we all forgot Steven Caulker ?

Who?

[Stainrod]

Who?

I’ll drink to that .

[QPRDave]

Clint Hill has got to be in that category.
Was Macca still with us in 2000/01?

[northampton rs]

Clint Hill has got to be in that category.
Was Macca still with us in 2000/01?

Think he finished up with us 1998 ?

[cocneycowboy]

Chris Samba , to add to the list.

Chris Samba was very poor for us,not for Blackburn, but glad to see him go back to Russia

[northampton rs]

Chris Samba was very poor for us,not for Blackburn, but glad to see him go back to Russia

Very true, he cost an awful lot and didn’t deliver.
just wanted to throw him into the mix.