Best defender last 20 years

[Abseits]

One day we will sell Rob for a fee that will be more than we paid for all of the defenders mentioned above combined. Have Oxford got any sell-on percentage due..... they could be copping £20mil themselves.

[Dono77]

Richard Dunne for me

[cross it Dave]

Did Dunn and Nelsen play in the same team?

[Kingaustin]

Loved Damian Stewart
but for me got to be hill

[MYU]

One day we will sell Rob for a fee that will be more than we paid for all of the defenders mentioned above combined. Have Oxford got any sell-on percentage due..... they could be copping £20mil themselves.

He'll end up leaving on a free or low price.

[dave58]

Danny Maddix left HQ in 2001 so only just makes it if it's last 20 years, one ofthe best man for man markers in the game at the time rarely let us down, Like Clint never let the club down, Dunne, Karl Walker when on loan too

[SheepRanger]

I liked Clarke Carlisle and Steve Palmer. Danny Shittu too.

Dickie has got some going to be as good as Clarisle though - excellent defender.

[Abseits]

He'll end up leaving on a free or low price.

No no no. He reminds me of emerging Phil Jones..... if we time it just right we can get £227 million for him. It's easy to scoff at Phil Jones today but there were a few years when he had the world at his feet, Timing, it's all about timing - I get the feeling the BOS debacle is a watershed moment and we won't be giving away our jewels for peanuts or for free ever again.

[SeamansGloves]

Richard Dunne... solid

[72bus]

Richard dunne for me , samba was useless my abiding memory of him was berbatov tearing him a new one at craven cottage