Is Joe Lumley better then Alex Smithies?

[cross it Dave]

Was Phil Parkes better than Seaman?

[Stanley]

Was Phil Parkes better than Seaman?

I would say so. Not much in it though.

[QPRDave]

No....No he isn't......Lummers v Smithies

[QPRDave]

Best keeper here since Stescal whatever the spellin, is Paddy Kenny

[acricketer]

Was Phil Parkes better than Seaman?

Parkes had a better tache.

[Timmy the Doc]

I'm starting to think Greeno's kicking was better than Lumley's...Don't understand why he kicks the ball that wide.

[1973 ranger]

Lumley is young keeper who hasconly become a first team regular this season. A half decent keeper who has to improve bundles to be compared to keepers of the recent past.

[Shepherds Mush]

Is Lumley better than Smithies ? I've no doubt he will be in the future.

[knocker]

Makes me nervous every time he leaves his line. And don't start me on his kicking.

[Shania]

These last few weeks he has suffered from playing behind a messy defence. As a result of that, he seems mentally drained and makes mistakes and loses concentration on the whole. Still a very promising keeper, Joe Lumley!

[qpr]

I personally wouldn’t want Alex Smithies back if given an option. I believe Lumley is better

I would know take Smithies back actually, sorry old me,,, you know nothing !!