Is Joe Lumley better then Alex Smithies?

[Shepherds Mush]

Paddy Kenny kept 24 clean sheets in the promotion season. That's some record to beat !!

[qpr]

Paddy Kenny kept 24 clean sheets in the promotion season. That's some record to beat !!

I thought Paddy was outstanding at QPR, I wish we hadn’t bought Green

[Ginger Ninja]

LOOOOOOL. Rate Lumley but r u mad. Green hugely underrated. Better than kenny . Got us promoted. Was quality when we went up. England squad. Green>kenny>lumley> smithies. Agree smithies overrated because of pens. Not surprised he’s not getting any games. JN

Agree Green was great for us by and large, but he was nowhere near Kenny's level. 24 clean sheets in that season is some record.

[WeAreQPR12]

OK I think we've all gone a bit off track. The simple answer is no!

[1973 ranger]

Paddy was one of the best keepers I have seen at Rangers in over 40 years supporting the club. Lumley is in his first full season and had a brilliant start. Lets hope he does not get injured or suspended.

[qpr]

Dead split 19-19

[West Acton]

Smithies better but Lumley able replacement with big future

[Tarbie]

Not a fare comparison really. Smithies had a few hundred league games under his belt when we signed him. Lumley is still learning his trade!

[suttonranger]

Smithies
donrcreally really recall Lumley making that many saves compared to alex
if they’re on target they’re normally in
I’d like him to come for corners or crosses more considering his size

[dave58]

NO NO

[Joe90]

Smithies is much better than Lumley. Not even close. Lumley has a LOT to work on. Terrible distribution and switches off occasionally, like last night when he was nearly tackled by the Pompey forward. Lumley has potential and will get better, but if Smithies was still with us he'd be first choice keeper no questions.

Bit harsh to compare the two as they've got very difference experience, would be interesting to see how Smithies performed when he started playing first team football at this level and compare the two.

[Pinkie]

Agree Green was great for us by and large, but he was nowhere near Kenny's level. 24 clean sheets in that season is some record.

Greens a awful keeper, soo slow footwork wise, werent a fan of his at all & kenny was better in my opinion.

[cross it Dave]

I voted Smithies, only based on up today, in another 2-3 years and Lumley will be better, I think and hope.

[Sleeping Giants]

Jurgen Sommer for me...lols

[Ginger Ninja]

Jurgen Sommer for me...lols

Ademola Bankole...what a keeper