Alex Mccarthy

[MattyRangers]

I thought McCarthy had some decent kicking distance wise, even got it near their box, something greeno never has done. I think it looked cack because no one was that high up the pitch. They were probably used to getting the ball before the halfway line

Well surely if the keeper looks up & sees nobody is that far up the pitch, you don't kick it that far up the pitch knowing nobody is there?

[nasser95]

Well surely if the keeper looks up & sees nobody is that far up the pitch, you don't kick it that far up the pitch knowing nobody is there?

True but I think he at least has the technique right. We may have a keeper who can actually work with the ball at his feet

[MYU]

Well surely if the keeper looks up & sees nobody is that far up the pitch, you don't kick it that far up the pitch knowing nobody is there?

I think he was expecting the players to put a little effort in and run, even he realised that was too much to ask.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Voted green out of sheer loyalty. Happy with mccarthy to be our number one if green moves though.

[bakes8]

Thanks for your effort Greeno but it's time for McCarthy.

[Lunar Jetman]

As the choice is to choose between the two I would opt for the younger fella. Greeno has been great for us, especially when his first period was competing against the Brazillian chap. He has been reliable over the last two seasons and yes he has made mistakes but tell me a keeper in the PL who hasn't.
On another front, Matty mentioned AM's kicking as poo, we all know Greeno's is dire as well. Makes you wonder what sort of coaching they are both getting.

Coaching to kick a football properly?? I'd hope this is something they should be able to do by default or at least practice themselves...