eff off rio

[QPR Richard]

We'll have to agree to disagree on the supposed merits of Rio Ferdinand. I think his best days are long gone, obviously you disagree.

[QPRDave]

In your opinion....People said exactly the same of Dunne, Hill, Helguson etc....How easy is it to condemn someone from behind a keyboard?....Personally I think he can still do a job.

Spot on

[fisnik]

We'll have to agree to disagree on the supposed merits of Rio Ferdinand. I think his best days are long gone, obviously you disagree.

Just because his best days are gone doesn't mean he can't still do a job for us. We don't need a world beater, we need to finish 17th.

[Ablockhoop]

I can't believe people are even testing his ability to play for us. Rio is top notch. He will be back in the team and prove everyone wrong

[Manx Hoop]

But why take the chance, we dont need him

[fisnik]

But why take the chance, we dont need him

What chance do you mean? How do you know that we don't need him? Can you foresee what injuries or suspensions we'll have in the future?

[QPR Richard]

I can't believe people are even testing his ability to play for us. Rio is top notch. He will be back in the team and prove everyone wrong

Why didn't Man Utd hang onto him if he's, "top notch" as you put it? Genuine question.

[Ablockhoop]

Are you actually saying that we should have the same calibre player as Man Utd? How comes united got rid of Vidic and eves aswell.. Are they not 'top notch'

[QPR Richard]

Are you actually saying that we should have the same calibre player as Man Utd? How comes united got rid of Vidic and eves aswell.. Are they not 'top notch'

No, I asked a simple question which I thought you'd be able to answer. Obviously not.

[Kevin Mcleod]

they got rid of him cos the new manager wanted to start again on his defence with younger players.

[fisnik]

So we shouldn't sign any players that are surplus to requirements at Man Utd or for that matter any club. Right?

[Kevin Mcleod]

So we shouldn't sign any players that are surplus to requirements at Man Utd or for that matter any club. Right?

If that team are much better than us and the player is good enough then course we still should take a risk now and then.

[fisnik]

That's my point exactly. Seems Richard doesn't agree.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Agree mate, really would like to see rio given another chance now we are more solid and understand each other as a team.

[QPR Richard]

So we shouldn't sign any players that are surplus to requirements at Man Utd or for that matter any club. Right?

That's not what I said. Please take time to read what I've written.