Sherwood, Pulis or Hoddle?

[West London is Rss]

There's no point in worrying.. Any manager comes in is a risk and will have reasons against him of why it might now work.

For where we are now, Pulis is the man.. If it was the start of the season then maybe Sherwood would be the man.

[Rangersw12]

There's no point in worrying.. Any manager comes in is a risk and will have reasons against him of why it might now work.

For where we are now, Pulis is the man.. If it was the start of the season then maybe Sherwood would be the man.

The same way people like you thought Redknapp was the man as well !!

The fans are just as bad as the board when it comes to managerial appointments and signings

[Geng]

There's no point in worrying.. Any manager comes in is a risk and will have reasons against him of why it might now work.

For where we are now, Pulis is the man.. If it was the start of the season then maybe Sherwood would be the man.

Lol, ok cool. Let's just appoint Joe Kinnear

[dave58]

Pulis for me the football won't be pretty but it will be effective and hardworking

[hh9]

Has Pulis ever won anything - I don't think so - what is the hype?
He has managed Bournemouth, Gillingham, Bristol City, Portsmouth, Stoke and Cr.Palace - non of the as big as QPR
Almost 60 years - old school
No thanks

[dave58]

Has Pulis ever won anything - I don't think so - what is the hype?
He has managed Bournemouth, Gillingham, Bristol City, Portsmouth, Stoke and Cr.Palace - non of the as big as QPR
Almost 60 years - old school
No thanks

and what have Hoddle & Sherwood won as managers

[Loneranger80]

As i may have said previously... I think it will be TS esp with the arrival of Sir Les... but in the same breath is there any real indication that Harry is on his way??...

[West London is Rss]

Lol, ok cool. Let's just appoint Joe Kinnear

What a stupid thing to say.

[West London is Rss]

Not sure we are in the position to be wanting managers who have won things?

I'll tell you what the hype in reason years is..

Getting a mediocre Palace team to mid-table from being dead and buried.. he also won manager of the year last season but hey, he aint big enough for QPR is he?
He also established Stoke and made them what they are today.

[Rangersw12]

Not sure we are in the position to be wanting managers who have won things?

I'll tell you what the hype in reason years is..

Getting a mediocre Palace team to mid-table from being dead and buried.. he also won manager of the year last season but hey, he aint big enough for QPR is he?
He also established Stoke and made them what they are today.

Spent millions doing it whilst playing horrible dirty unattractive long ball football

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Finally a bit of sense.
And not only is Hughes doing a better job with Stoke, Our other ex manager Warnock is currently doing just as good a job with Palace as Pulis did.There form hasn't dipped from last season.

For me Sherwood gets us back to basics in the sense of being a proper coach who will not only look at bringing the youth team players through, and improving them but will look at bringing in lesser name players, who want to play for the club and who want to learn.His league record for Spurs was pretty impressive, although he needs to learn when to keep his mouth shut.He will also sort out alot of the shirkers we have in our current squad, and he also has a good relationship with Les.No brainier for me.

Very early days there mate.

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Has Pulis ever won anything - I don't think so - what is the hype?
He has managed Bournemouth, Gillingham, Bristol City, Portsmouth, Stoke and Cr.Palace - non of the as big as QPR
Almost 60 years - old school
No thanks

You could argue all the last three are at least as big as us I am afraid.

[hh9]

Actually we are in a very good position.
Many would like to work for TF who is splashing the money and has ideas about new stadium, and has been able to attract some good players to the club
Small thinking is not going to take this club anywhere

IMO What QPR stands for and the football Pulis teams play is like trying to mix oil and water

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Actually we are in a very good position.
Many would like to work for TF who is splashing the money and has ideas about new stadium, and has been able to attract some good players to the club
Small thinking is not going to take this club anywhere

IMO What QPR stands for and the football Pulis teams play is like trying to mix oil and water

This is true but it will be another short term solution no doubt.

[stanistheman]

Sherwood - we don't have any decent youth players for him to improve, he has no tactical awareness and we are almost certain to concede 5 goals a game and get relegated. He's the easy option, but if TF goes for him I will start losing faith in his ability to make the right decisions. Big no.

Pulis - plays ugly football but it surely can't get worse than it is now. I wouldn't be certain of survival even if he came here, but he is the best of the 3 IMO.

Hoddle - just another shady back room pal of Arry's, it will be more of the same. Has had little effect compared to McClaren last year.

Pulis of the 3. Please, enough of this ex-Spurs mob screwing us over.

I would also go for Pulis as I think he offers the best chance of avoiding relegation. I am not sure about the ugly football though, as I don't recall Palace always being dull to watch under his management. Yes, it would be direct, but as you say, it can't be worse than the drivel we have been watching under Redknapp (how many games has he managed QPR to a 0 scoreline?).