Hoillett

[West Acton]

Is he left or right footed as he always cuts in onto his right which became a bit frustrating as the Blackburn right back read it most of the time

I cant work him out as the ability is there and after his start to the season I thought we were in store for a great season from him but he's not producing in my view what he is capable off

The one time he went for the right back he done him comfortably and the guy ended up dragging him down and getting a yellow. For me once that guy was on a yellow Hoilett should have gone for the throat and just kept going at him as he no doubt would have got a second yellow but it felt like he just never fancied it

[theblackmafia.]

He aint producing for a few reasons: He thinks he is better than he is. He thinks he is better than the Championship. He trys to be M.O.M every game. He wants to be noticed badly. I'm sure there are more points people can throw in/argue over.

[Yousef]

He is not up for the games.

He doesn't want to fight.

[West Acton]

My take to some extent is that he does not trust his hamstring and hence does not want to go at players and fully break into a sprint in case it goes

[W12_Ranger]

He is starting to look like SWP Mk II

[West Acton]

He is starting to look like SWP Mk II

W12 that did cross my mind

I would give SWP another chance personally and would defo have him on the bench as he has looked lively this season when he has played

[theblackmafia.]

SWP of receng times not when the same age. SWP was a cracking little player 10 years ago and it's a shame he's been shite for the last 9 years and 11 months!

[QPR Richard]

He's a bit one dimensional I think. Likes to run at players then cut in. Personally, I'd prefer Traore on the left. Think back to the Man City game and the cross Traore delivered for Mackie. We need more of that.

I think our attack suffers from our wingers underperforming. We know Barton and Carroll are capable of defence-splitting passes, but our wide men just aren't delivering crosses for the forwards. That's why I believe 4-4-2 isn't working well when deployed.

If our wingers put more crosses in, it would add another dimension to our attack, and consequently more goal-scoring opportunities.

[West Acton]

He's a bit one dimensional I think. Likes to run at players then cut in. Personally, I'd prefer Traore on the left. Think back to the Man City game and the cross Traore delivered for Mackie. We need more of that.

I think our attack suffers from our wingers underperforming. We know Barton and Carroll are capable of defence-splitting passes, but our wide men just aren't delivering crosses for the forwards. That's why I believe 4-4-2 isn't working well when deployed.

If our wingers put more crosses in, it would add another dimension to our attack, and consequently more goal-scoring opportunities.

[Brightsparx]

Traore gonna live off that 1 cross. Had two chances to deliver yesterday but run one out if play and the other gave away. Agreed on hoilett poor should not start could be good coming off the bench for last 30mins, as when he starts has a stroll up

[rickyranger]

Lot of criticism for Hoillett but he still looks more threatening than Phillips. Yes there are the odd bits of promise from Phillips but he does some very average things. Need to remember at 5 million he cost more than Hoillett. He rarely beats his man doesn't have the lightening pace many were saying and is very poor defensively. Maybe needs time but you can only wait so long and Phillips deserves criticism just as much if not more than Hoillett.

[West Acton]

Lot of criticism for Hoillett but he still looks more threatening than Phillips. Yes there are the odd bits of promise from Phillips but he does some very average things. Need to remember at 5 million he cost more than Hoillett. He rarely beats his man doesn't have the lightening pace many were saying and is very poor defensively. Maybe needs time but you can only wait so long and Phillips deserves criticism just as much if not more than Hoillett.

RR I think we have been watching different players the last four of five games as I think Phillips has got better and better by each game, granted was a bit quitter yesterday.

As for lightening pace he showed that second half when Barton put one over the top and from being on the halfway line with two centre backs with yards on him he caught them up and we ended up with a corner had that leg race been two more paces he would have been through on goal

On rarely beating his man well Hoillet on current form never beats his man nor does he currently put any quality in the box. On current form if I had to choose between the two I would opt for Phillips

[QPR Richard]

Traore gonna live off that 1 cross. Had two chances to deliver yesterday but run one out if play and the other gave away. Agreed on hoilett poor should not start could be good coming off the bench for last 30mins, as when he starts has a stroll up

Here's a little clip of Traore.

http://youtu.be/ch8tGrry6ok

Some good crosses in it.

[West Mids QPR]

He is not up for the games.

He doesn't want to fight.

With respect, nonsense...

It takes 8 games to get match fit. Hoillet needs that run, which brings confidence, which is what a winger/striker needs more than anything.

Actually, despite all the uproar, I thought yesterday was a good point against a very well organised Blackburn side. Should have been out of sight by half time...

[Kevin Mcleod]

He is really shite. Would prefer swp to start and that if he had to and that is the honest truth. At least swp does actually pass now and again. Dont need either of them though imo. Drop hoilett, always play phillips on one wing and let aj move from just behind austin to the other wing when needed to. Really cant see how harry looks at hoilett and thinks 'triffick kad, hes deffo starting again next week'. Most frustrating wasteful do nothing ever player since adel went all diva and became shite as well.