Why sell Remy?

[Hoop-du-Jour]

He deffo wants to be located in london given the choice for family reasons, he said so the other day. But id imagine that means with either arsenal, spurs or chelsea.

May even be as close as the Scrubs yet, in his own cell.

[Ricky]

Totally agree if we go up and had to replace him would cost at least £20M so why let him go for £6-8M we wouldn't get get anyone as good fot that type of money? we should deffo keep him if we're promoted, I'm sure he'd rather live in London?

How can you possibly be sure where he would rather live?

I would have thought he prefers playing at a nice ground in front of tens of thousands more than we get. Anyone saying we are in as good a position as Newcastle, are seriously deluded.

[Shepherds Mush]

Can you see Remy working his socks off in a 4-5-1 like Charlie does week in, week out? He wont be at us or Newcastle next season.

[Ricky]

He deffo wants to be located in london given the choice for family reasons, he said so the other day. But id imagine that means with either arsenal, spurs or chelsea.

If this was the case, would he not have simply chosen not to go out on loan?!?!?!? He had a contract, so didnt have to move anywhere.

People get a bit carried away sometimes. The bloke has no loaylty to us what-so-ever. He has only ever played for us at a low point for the club, so was probably well happy to get shot.

[DeepcutHoop]

Can you see Remy working his socks off in a 4-5-1 like Charlie does week in, week out? He wont be at us or Newcastle next season.

You're probably right on the last point, but although 4-5-1 may not be the best formation for him, has he really shown any lack of effort for us or Newcastle that would make you think he wouldn't put in a shift?

[Dazzer1977]

Think he'd rather be playing for newcastle than QPR to be fair

Remind me who he signed for on January?

[Kevin Mcleod]

If this was the case, would he not have simply chosen not to go out on loan?!?!?!? He had a contract, so didnt have to move anywhere.

People get a bit carried away sometimes. The bloke has no loaylty to us what-so-ever. He has only ever played for us at a low point for the club, so was probably well happy to get shot.

He would rather play in outer mongolia than the championship, staying put was not an option to him.

[Shepherds Mush]

You're probably right on the last point, but although 4-5-1 may not be the best formation for him, has he really shown any lack of effort for us or Newcastle that would make you think he wouldn't put in a shift?

He'd work but not as much as Charlie does. Though to be fair, he'd probably slot away more chances without having to do half the work!

[essex]

Best thing that could happen IMO is he bangs in 20+ goals this season and finishes a top-5 scorer and we sell him for a lot more than the 8mil we are reported to have paid for him.

[THE CAT]

Best thing that could happen IMO is he bangs in 20+ goals this season and finishes a top-5 scorer and we sell him for a lot more than the 8mil we are reported to have paid for him.

To be honest he must be worth a lot more than we paid for him now.

His scoring record to games must be among the best in the country over the past year in the Prem. If you look at the silly money paid for average strikers in this country who haven't socred goals regularly(eg, Carroll, Torres etc) he must be worth £20m now easily.

[Johnnykc]

To be honest he must be worth a lot more than we paid for him now.

His scoring record to games must be among the best in the country over the past year in the Prem. If you look at the silly money paid for average strikers in this country who haven't socred goals regularly(eg, Carroll, Torres etc) he must be worth £20m now easily.

If fatboy Torres is a £50m striker.......Remy is worth about 800 squillion about now......

[bhujio]

Best thing that could happen IMO is he bangs in 20+ goals this season and finishes a top-5 scorer and we sell him for a lot more than the 8mil we are reported to have paid for him.

Spot On as I see the best solution

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Hasn't he a release clause for the amount we paid for him? So if a million teams come in for him we can do nowt once they offer that price.

He's easily worth £15m minimum. Quality, clinical finisher.

[72bus]

remy will go where he is advised to go by his handlers , he's in the how and where can we make as much money as possible business . he is in the shop window at newcastle and if he keeps scoring his price goes up and his wage demands will follow . i dont know of any get out clauses but cant see him back with us unless france dont make brazil and he stops scoring . a good world cup and the likes of man city , madrid, psg ,barcelona the big hitters and payers cold come in for him

[dsqpr]

Loic Remy unsure over permanent Newcastle United deal (28th Oct, 2013)

http://www.caughtoffside.com/2013/10/28/loic-remy-unsure-over-permanent-newcastle-united-deal/

Seems as though it all depends on what happens in the next 6 months.