Worst 3 Signings Since We Were Promoted

[Smaug]

Granero - expected much more from him in terms of passing/keeping possession/making chances for others
Cesar - hasn't been that bad but Green isn't a much worse keeper than him and how much money have we wasted by getting him
Bosingwa- pretty much a ******

On other players like Park, I think he was never the kind of player at Man Utd to score many goals or create chances, but a more defensive players in breaking up play/tackling, I think he has been OK at that but his passing has also been very poor this season.

[Felt]

Think i would struggle picking 3 signings that have been decent tbh!

Granero (as other have said, huge fees, most probably wages to match - no wonder he's keen on staying)
Bosingwa (huge wages, long contract, pony)
Johnson (looked alright, but predictably out for the season pretty quickly meaning we were stuffed up front)

[silvercue]

Who do you think have been the worst 3 players signed since we were promoted?

1. SWP - Total and Utter failure. Utter waste of potential
2. Hoilett - how do we turn good players into pub players?
3. Andy Johnson - paid to sit in the treatment room. We knew he was injury prone.


I could name more......lot's more, but them for me.

[Hertford Hoop]

Toilet, has he done anything worth a mention?
Bosingwa, overated hasbean
Park/Ferdinand/Granero/SWP/Ceasar/Samba/the other Samba ....I can go on

[vanhoop]

Barton
Bosingwa
Park

Sez something when an on loan player in townsend out shines the rest

[Hitman34]

yes green shown 'laughing n joking' more than once on the telly when we were behind!

you got it facto

[qpr4life]

Im sure Green found it hilarious when Hughes ****ed him over and signed Cesar pre season as well....

[westsussexranger]

Im sure Green found it hilarious when Hughes ****ed him over and signed Cesar pre season as well....

and for this reason he cant be in the top three. hes had a great attitude as he hasnt complained about being on the bench

[Timmy the Doc]

1. Samba, we would have done better without him (Onuoha, Hill). Scored 0!
2. Granero, perhaps our worst midfielder this season.
3. Cesar. Very, very poor with crosses and don't know how to catch a ball. Green would have been better #1.

[qpr4life]

and for this reason he cant be in the top three. hes had a great attitude as he hasnt complained about being on the bench

Exactly

[Norths]

Exactly

Would you complain sitting on the bench collecting 40-50k a week?

[SuperHoopNik]

Park, Bosingwa and Johnson-Good player but is made of glass.

[Norths]

Yes, AJ was a disaster waiting to happen

[Tarbie]

Am I really only allowed 3? As an earlier poster said you'd struggle to pick 3 good ones!

Based purely on expectation against what they have actually delivered I'm gonna go as follows:

1.) Park
2.) Granero
3.) Samba

Junior Hoilett is very lucky not to make this list. Bosingwa isn't on there as I never really expected him to be that good anyway. In any other club Ferdinand, Mbia, Bothroyd, SWP, Barton, Zamora, Johnson, DJ Campbell, Young, Onouha, Diakite or Green would probably have made the list........just goes to how how incredibly bad we have been in the transfer market.

I really hope the board have learned their lesson and we start looking for the best up and coming talent rather than buying these overpaid has beens!

[silvercue]

can we change the list to 10?