Worst 3 Signings Since We Were Promoted

[Shepherds Mush]

Who do you think have been the worst 3 players signed since we were promoted?

1. Jose Bosingwa - awful attitude and cannot defend to save his life
2. Junior Hoilett - nowhere near the player he was and could be
3. SWP - past his best years ago

[vblockranger]

1. Park
2. Boswinga
3. Granero

hard to pick just 3 tbh

[qpr4life]

1. Granero - Cost a fortune, never came good
2. SWP - Fairly high wages, never played at his best
3. Boswinga - Didnt want to sit on the bench; enough said. OVERPAID

You really got to think about. The cost of the player, how good they was, where they came from etc.

These three IMO based on cost (Wages or transfer etc) have been the biggest let down. Shame really..

I think players like Junior and park just got away with it only because IMO they put in a shift and had bad injuries.

[MattyRangers]

Purely contribution / lack of on the pitch:

1) Samba. Hasn't scored or done anything too positive, cost us points and been at fault for numerous goals.
2) Andy Johnson. Played well in the few games he played so some might disagree with me putting him here, but I am doing so on the basis that he has literally played 3 games for us and so a massive waste of a signing IMO - not that we could have foreseen his injury of course.
3) Park. Not really done alot at all tbh.

Hoillett also worth a mention; had glimpses of showing what he can do - but on the whole he has been $hit.

[vblockranger]

Purely contribution / lack of on the pitch:

1) Samba. Hasn't scored or done anything too positive, cost us points and been at fault for numerous goals.
2) Andy Johnson. Played well in the few games he played so some might disagree with me putting him here, but I am doing so on the basis that he has literally played 3 games for us and so a massive waste of a signing IMO - not that we could have foreseen his injury of course.
3) Park. Not really done alot at all tbh.

Hoillett also worth a mention; had glimpses of showing what he can do - but on the whole he has been $hit.

Samba is a good shout actually

[Hitman34]

preformance wise

1, hoilett

2, park

3, granero.


attitude

1, bosingwa

2, cisse

3, green

[Factamondo]

zamora....couldnt care less attitude n more suited to offering kids rides on his back whilst wearing a straw hat on blackpool pleasure beach!

cris samba.....much championed on here yet for money spent/wages....give me a matty upson or liam ridgewell every time

any man utd castaway or loanee..........is it fergies way of getting 'revenge'???.....park/fabio/macheda..........other clubs loaned cleverely n welbeck!

[MattyRangers]

preformance wise

1, hoilett

2, park

3, granero.


attitude

1, bosingwa

2, cisse

3, green

Green?

[Factamondo]

yes green shown 'laughing n joking' more than once on the telly when we were behind!

[QPR Richard]

F**k me, there's so many contenders!

[Robsondinho]

Off the top of my head first 3 that come to mind:

Toilett
Bosingwa
Park

Parks performance against MK Dons is still without a doubt the worst performance I have seen ever from a pro footballer.

[Busheyboy]

Samba - cost a fortune, not a patch on freebie Nelsen
Boswinga - can't defend, shocking attitude problem
Hoilett - for a much sought after player, he's done nothing

Park, Granero & SWP wouldn't be far behind tbf

[Q.P.R Hunkdog]

A.Ferdinand
Bosingwa
Park

[MattyRangers]

Off the top of my head first 3 that come to mind:

Toilett
Bosingwa
Park

Parks performance against MK Dons is still without a doubt the worst performance I have seen ever from a pro footballer.

The scary thing is there's a few to rival this' Samba v Foolham & Hoilett vs Stoke come to mind

[vblockranger]

Think i would struggle picking 3 signings that have been decent tbh!