Marshy - Should he stay or should he go?

[DeepcutHoop]

Blimey. I didn't even say what politics it would imply you having, or whether or not I agreed with it myself.

Seems this is a topic many people here are completely incapable of discussing, and Marshy shouldn't be blamed for that.

As a standalone thing you might be right, but taken in the greater context of Marshy being the centre of the WATRB universe at the moment, it was ill-advised at best, and probably just deliberately downright provocative of Marshy to go down that route in that thread.

The General chat forum is there for that conversation, but maybe doesn't have a big enough audience for Marshy.

[jfish]

You are a **** of the highest order.

And here is why we're not allowed nice things/political discussions.....

No need for that tbf

Not sure why you feel the need to stir, I stand by it.

[vblockranger]

Blimey. I didn't even say what politics it would imply you having, or whether or not I agreed with it myself.

Seems this is a topic many people here are completely incapable of discussing, and Marshy shouldn't be blamed for that.

How long have you lived over here in the UK?

When is the poll starting to get rid of geng?

[Rangers77]

Shameful.

[DeepcutHoop]

You are a **** of the highest order.

And here is why we're not allowed nice things/political discussions.....

No need for that tbf

[Geng]

Blimey. I didn't even say what politics it would imply you having, or whether or not I agreed with it myself.

Seems this is a topic many people here are completely incapable of discussing, and Marshy shouldn't be blamed for that.

[MattyRangers]

The rest of you are getting your views across in that thread too, why shouldn't Marshy?

Wishing a soldier RIP, especially one you don't know personally, isn't a non-political act.

I didn't realise Marshy had a boyfriend....

[vblockranger]

Thats why I said I give up...

My other response would have been full of censored expletives which would have probably got geng edging towards climax, its like some get off on this trolling lark.

Same as Marshy...posts for effect.

[Norths]

Thats why I said I give up...

My other response would have been full of censored expletives which would have probably got geng edging towards climax, its like some get off on this trolling lark.

[jfish]

The rest of you are getting your views across in that thread too, why shouldn't Marshy?

Wishing a soldier RIP, especially one you don't know personally, isn't a non-political act.

You are a **** of the highest order.

[Norths]

The rest of you are getting your views across in that thread too, why shouldn't Marshy?

Wishing a soldier RIP, especially one you don't know personally, isn't a non-political act.

I give up...

You and Marshy a match made in heaven.

[Geng]

I never said he was.

He has used a thread dedicated to people that want to pay their respects to a man that has died serving his country and happens to be a fellow QPR fan to get yet another of his views across.

Its as simple as that.

The rest of you are getting your views across in that thread too, why shouldn't Marshy?

Wishing a soldier RIP, especially one you don't know personally, isn't a non-political act.

[jfish]

He didn't 'randomly bring it up' though. It was a thread about a guy who died in Afghanistan, so of course the context of his death (the war, the decision to send him there, why people are trying to kill our soldiers etc etc) is relevant.

Are we seriously so immature and incapable of debate here that the only responses allowed in that thread are variants on "RIP"?

Clueless and very insensitive

[Rangers77]

He didn't 'randomly bring it up' though. It was a thread about a guy who died in Afghanistan, so of course the context of his death (the war, the decision to send him there, why people are trying to kill our soldiers etc etc) is relevant.

Are we seriously so immature and incapable of debate here that the only responses allowed in that thread are variants on "RIP"?

No. Its because we're respectful and decent. In that thread.