Steven Naismith

[Tarbie]

6 Premier League clubs have made an approach for Naismith apparently. 1 is Everton and another is bound to be West Brom who have already tried to sign him a couple of times, could we be one of the other 4?

[QPRDave]

could be................hope not

[Tarbie]

could be................hope not

I don't think he'd be that bad a signing on a free, definite improvement on DJ and Betty!

[Ric-Roc]

What's his natural position? He's a midfielder isn't he?

He's alright I guess but would hope we're looking at much better personally.

[QPRDave]

What's his natural position? He's a midfielder isn't he?

He's alright I guess but would hope we're looking at much better personally.

yeah agree

[Tarbie]

What's his natural position? He's a midfielder isn't he?

He's alright I guess but would hope we're looking at much better personally.

He plays as a winger or 2nd striker.

It's one of those where people will talk Naismith down because he's only ever played in a rubbish league in Scotland...........much like people on here talked down Jelavic when we were linked with him.

To be honest, in my opinion he would be a squad player but as I say, on a free I'm pretty sure he's give us more options than DJ and Betty put together.

[SuperHoopNik]

If he comes to the PL, he won't be as good of a goalscorer as Jelavic, but would be a very good winger or second striker as someone said above

[Mattyqpr]

He would improve the squad so a definite yes from me and on a free transfer.

[Deadend_Friend]

Fantastic player. Would much rather him partner Cisse than Zamora

[MattyRangers]

Fantastic player. Would much rather him partner Cisse than Zamora

Personally, think Zamora is twice the player Naismith is. Only ever played in the 2 bob Scottish league and hasnt exactly set that alight. Without starting another Zamora debate, what he does up there compliments Cisse so well. he does a great job and is onto a thankless task, just re-watch the Arsenal home game and then tell me if you think Naismith would be able to do anywhere the job Bobby does.

Dont get me worng im not saying naismith is pony, he is obviously a pretty good player, and I wouldnt mind him on a free transfer if he's happy to be a squad player, but me, personally, wouldnt have him in our starting 11 over Zamora n Cisse.

[Ginger Ninja]

He was good in the Scottish Prem, but then again, so was Kris Boyd...
Personally don't think he's any better than Zamora up front, and definitely nowhere near as good as Mackie on the wing.