Clint or Anton?

[Andyqpr123]

Clint's a stopper and Ferdy's a sweeper, they compliment each other but lack height...

[Yousef]

Hill

[qprted]

yes it must be hill he is a lion heart amongst men and dosnt have any concept of defeat

[W12_Ranger]

Very simples....

Ferdinand was playing without confidence and guidance and has a tendency to lack concentration sometimes and vocals.
and he was hardly an inspiration for other players
All this changed for the good when a Real Commander became his partner in central defense

So for me without a doubt ... HILL

Don't let yourselves be fooled , Ferdinand looks on paper the better player and more experienced.
But.... it was Hill who kept us together and showed what a leader must be in the back apart from Chelsea away.
POTY so deserves that captains band.

Well said

[NW9_RANGER]

Ferdinand did an ok job last year but he's not good enough, he seems to be away with the fairies at times. Hill is a better defender so it's a no brainer. Clint Hill should be captain.... However... If we are aiming for a top ten finish, both need replacing. Harsh but true

[MattyRangers]

Ferdinand did an ok job last year but he's not good enough, he seems to be away with the fairies at times. Hill is a better defender so it's a no brainer. Clint Hill should be captain.... However... If we are aiming for a top ten finish, both need replacing. Harsh but true

Yep. No room for sentiment in football. Hill was superb last year dont get me wrong and I think hes a top top bloke, but if we are looking to push on and up the table we really need a player of his mould but abit younger and sharper, in the mould of somebody like Shawcross IMO (although not him as he would cost a fortune I should imagine!). Somebody like him next to Anton would be fine for me, Anton looks alot better when he is with a commanding CB. When tis him who needs to be the leader though (ie when he was with Gabbidon), he looks like a rabbit in headlights at times.

[QPR1234]

interesting..

[stainrodisalegend]

Very strange how so many people want the captain to be somebody who wont actually be in the team.

[Hitman34]

Well stainrod, i would start hill this season. he was superb in the centre last time out and think he deserves his spot.

give him the arm band and watch him roar!

[stainrodisalegend]

he played out of his skin the back end of last season at centre back and will always be grateful for that but if people are serious about us being a mid-table prem team and expecting clint hill to be our first choice centre back next season then im seriously worried.

[qpr]

Anton

[w12dave]

Don't know if anyone will agree with me but I would like to see one top defender bought in to partner Onuoha at centre-back

Ferdinand, Hill and Nelsen on standby for suspension or injuries for the long season ahead of us...

[stanistheman]

Hill is a better defender than Ferdinand. Ferdinand started well but his for suffered after the Chelsea incident came to light.

[Norths]

Hill is a better defender than Ferdinand. Ferdinand started well but his for suffered after the Chelsea incident came to light.

Anton had a pretty decent ending to the season imo, was solid against Spurs at home.

[paulmason]

Hill all day long as he has a brain and can organise.

I suppose the players and fans wrote the wrong name down when voting.