Team for tomorrow ?

[Dando]

Cerny

Ramage
Hall
Gorkss
Vignal

routledge
Mahon
rowlands
Balanta

Vine
Ageymang

subs
Tarby
Pellicori
connolly
marshall
buzacky

why hall over Connolly and stewart? I am completely puzzled why anybody could put Hall ahead of any of our defenders??

[NW9_RANGER]

--------------cerny------------
ramage-----hall-----gorkss----connolly
routledge----rowlands-----mahon----balanta
-------agyemang------vine---------

[NW9_RANGER]

why hall over Connolly and stewart? I am completely puzzled why anybody could put Hall ahead of any of our defenders??

agree with the connolly part of ur question, but ur surely joking about stewart

[kingo]

Based on the fact that I don't think Buzz is 100% and I think Vignal will be given another run out and Conners, Faurlin not risked.

Cerny
Ramage, Gorkks, Stewart/Hall, Vignal
Routledge, Rowlands, Mahon, Balanta
Pelicori, Vine/Adel

[WALKONBY]

Marshall
ramage
stewart
gorkss
barrowdale
routledge
rowlands
mahon
balanta
pellicori
tarrabat

[Dando]

agree with the connolly part of ur question, but ur surely joking about stewart

why joking about Stewart? My starting line up would be connolly and gorkks, however there is no doubt whatsoever that Stewart would be next in line - not hall. Stewart got our player of the year, deserveadly so. He may not be the most composed but he will always clear his lines and will dominate in the air. He will also get some vital goals. What does Hall do?? Look how many goals we let in when hall plays - its not a coincedence - id like to see some stats

[WeAreQPR12]

I agree with Gill's post. Hall is not the answer

[Dando]

i just worked out im Gill? afterall this time! lol I know everyone has their opinions, and im not always right - but for me its totally clear than Stewart should be picked over hall any day. Must be a fan who is clueless about football or doesnt see the games regulalry - sorry to sound harsh, but it winds me up! Just watch us let in shocking goals if hall plays

[NW9_RANGER]

oh come on, the lad is premiership material - just lol? stewart is a poor defender, being able to hoof a ball up the field does not mean a good thing, he panics way too much his positioning leaves is awful and id also like to see the stats on how many goals weve conceded when stewart plays. granted u r right about the goals, hes good with his head but i dont think thats enough.

[WALKONBY]

I think all new signings if fit should start tomorrow .
So fans could see what there are like .
Alot of people are making judgement without seeing them play.

[BennyBoyRs]

I think all new signings if fit should start tomorrow .
So fans could see what there are like .
Alot of people are making judgement without seeing them play.

Agree, hence why I can't put any of them in my starting lineup.

I know nowt about them.

[Dando]

oh come on, the lad is premiership material - just lol? stewart is a poor defender, being able to hoof a ball up the field does not mean a good thing, he panics way too much his positioning leaves is awful and id also like to see the stats on how many goals weve conceded when stewart plays. granted u r right about the goals, hes good with his head but i dont think thats enough.

If hall is premiership quality, why wasnt he playing last year? Stewart was a rock at the back, and one of the main reasons we had one of the best defences in the division last year. When hall plays, we concede far more goals, and he wins nothing in the air! Agaisnt premiership teams, he is composed as he has time on the ball - but the fact is that we are in the championship - and we need players at the back who are going to get long balls away, and clear their lines. Stewart didnt get player of the year for nothing. At the end of the day, the defence is paid to get the ball away - not to look pretty on the ball. Stewart does his job

[NW9_RANGER]

i just worked out im Gill? afterall this time! lol I know everyone has their opinions, and im not always right - but for me its totally clear than Stewart should be picked over hall any day. Must be a fan who is clueless about football or doesnt see the games regulalry - sorry to sound harsh, but it winds me up! Just watch us let in shocking goals if hall plays

??? where u come up with that u :girl: what makes u think that ur right. i live and breathe football mate, i would choose connolly and gorkss over hall n stewart, i find it amazing that neway would play stewart over hall. hopefully jim will see things my way ;) maybe he dont know what hes doing either :boss:

[NW9_RANGER]

okay dandylion. ur opinion has been noted hopefully hall can change ur mind this season

[Dando]

okay dandylion. ur opinion has been noted hopefully hall can change ur mind this season

everyone entitled to their opinions, but i dont think we will ever agree about this one!