Jamie Mackie

[Deise hoop]

Keep both.(for now)
With better players now comin to the club.it could bring out the best in mackie and tommy smith.

[brightonr]

Hi Gareth,

How's the Championship these days ?

[GarethGardner]

Im amazed by the split opinion on Mackie, I thought he was well liked.
Hard working players is what Cardiff are full of this year so i think Mackie will suit us. specially with the amount of Scots we have here at the moment..
With Malky we got such a different approach compared to last seasons individuals.
Im not surprised at all Bothroyd flopped. Such a talented player but his attitude is awful and he loved the Cardiff pitch he sat down on it so much.
Make sure you guys stay up and knock them Jacks back down to the Championship.
Whats happening with Taarabt ? Huge player last year and still seems to be sulking with you, i fully expected him to go in January

[Yousef]

Keep Smith and sell Mackie.

[UB6-RANGER]

If hughes tells mackie to look up even 3 times a game he would be a vastly improved player.

[QPRWEBBIE]

Let me put one thing to you before you cart Mackie off to Mongolia or somewhere..............it wasnt that long ago that Helguson was beeing touted as crap and not good enough for then the championship but now or was our main striker and is top goal scorer.Adel had mixed views on here (not good enough for the prem) so lets look at Mackie,exploded in the championship but got a bad injury and only been back a few games and to be fair playing in a poor team with no support around him.Anybody who has played the game at a reasonable level knows it takes a while to get your confidence back as well as your touch,if and a big if he gets a game in this new look team he might just surprise you and feel because of what he showed before injury and his 100% work ethic he should be given a slot in our 25

[BennyBoyRs]

Keep Tommy, let Jamie go. Reason being, Tommy is an intelligent player, and I feel he can help out at times.

Jamie needs to be playing more regular, and he'll help Cardiff no-end. Not that helping them is a good thing, but it'll be good for Mackie.

[Tarbie]

1.5m for Mackie?...........Does he need a lift?!!!!

[72bus]

keep jamie as a impact sub will run his heart out for 15/20 mins

[Factamondo]

would be a fantastic move for jamie imho.........that lower league level is where he thrives......

[OldSchool]

Let me put one thing to you before you cart Mackie off to Mongolia or somewhere..............it wasnt that long ago that Helguson was beeing touted as crap and not good enough for then the championship but now or was our main striker and is top goal scorer.Adel had mixed views on here (not good enough for the prem) so lets look at Mackie,exploded in the championship but got a bad injury and only been back a few games and to be fair playing in a poor team with no support around him.Anybody who has played the game at a reasonable level knows it takes a while to get your confidence back as well as your touch,if and a big if he gets a game in this new look team he might just surprise you and feel because of what he showed before injury and his 100% work ethic he should be given a slot in our 25

His neck must still be injured as he now seems incapable of looking up! Neve noticed this before his injury so maybe he's just tying too hard to impress? Just can't see him improving enough to make an impact at this level. After 5 minutes the left backs have worked him out.

[Norths]

we need to recoup some money and 1.5-2m is good business for jamie

[stainrodisalegend]

Think maybe Mackie should go on loan.

Why? He is what he is. He isn't suddenly going to learn aged 27 or whatever he is how to run towards the goal while keeping the ball under control as opposed to running into the corner flag or into the stand...

[QPRWEBBIE]

His neck must still be injured as he now seems incapable of looking up! Neve noticed this before his injury so maybe he's just tying too hard to impress? Just can't see him improving enough to make an impact at this level. After 5 minutes the left backs have worked him out.

probably trying to hard but has his head down as he carries a lot of players on his shoulders and at least gives committment.What at the moment does swp do more than mackie..Mackie head down and tries to take players on...SWP goes to take a player on stops and passes back at least JM trys to drive the team on. Not suggesting he is one of our better players but certainly isnt the worse

[MYU]

1.5m for Mackie?...........Does he need a lift?!!!!

Don't worry... I'll do it!