Jason Puncheon has returned to Southampton

[Shania]

I always thought Hogan should be given a go , he always looks decent when i watch him.

[DouDou_87]

Have I missed something here? Since when did Hogan become our superstar?

No one batted an eyelid when he was loaned to Charlton and only a few were surprised when he was left out of the 25. He didn't even feature much in the 2nd half of our season last year?! All of a sudden he needs to be given a chance again.

Don't get me wrong, I like him and I thought he was tremendous at times for us in the Championship, but he is not a Premiership player!

[Mellowhoop]

Nether was clint hill, Derry, helguson to name a few. All done ok so far.. What is a prem player? I don't think he will set the world alight but should of been given a go instead of a few others.

[DouDou_87]

Nether was clint hill, Derry, helguson to name a few. All done ok so far.. What is a prem player? I don't think he will set the world alight but should of been given a go instead of a few others.

Fair point, there is no definitive criteria that makes a Prem player.

However on this seasons performances I would say Derry has really struggled to make the step up and at times has looked well out of his depth.

More than happy to eat a big fat slice of humble pie if I'm wrong about Hogan.

[MattyRangers]

Have I missed something here? Since when did Hogan become our superstar?

No one batted an eyelid when he was loaned to Charlton and only a few were surprised when he was left out of the 25. He didn't even feature much in the 2nd half of our season last year?! All of a sudden he needs to be given a chance again.

Don't get me wrong, I like him and I thought he was tremendous at times for us in the Championship, but he is not a Premiership player!

[QPRDave]

Give the lad a chance, some on here said when Clint was selected he would be well found out but he wasn't and has handled the prem well imo

[Bigdave]

If only Hogan would run at full backs and try to beat them with his pace he could be a decent shout.

[rangerforevereastcote]

Would rather Hogan than Mackie also.

Deserves a shot.

[rangerforevereastcote]

we all discuss loyalty , hogan played a big part n our early season form last year, has been a good servant at the club never hear him moaning , he deserved a chance and i felt gutted fo rhim that places in the squad given to puncheon and dyer , people who contributed nothing to the cause whilst someone who had got overlooked

[QPRDave]

Mason will be after you in a minute ranger telling you we support QPR not individuals
No room for loyalty or sentiment.

[rangerforevereastcote]

Mason will be after you in a minute ranger telling you we support QPR not individuals
No room for loyalty or sentiment.

I might get a pass as have agreed on a few things recently lol