Best/bad signing so far

[Yousef]

Who is our best signing this season and who is the worse?
Best: Young
Worst: Puncheon.

[stainrodisalegend]

TBH none of our signings have set the world alight, though players like Traore have certainly shown glimpses of real promise and several others have the potential to come good. Probably our best two players against Swans were Ali and Adel. In earlier weeks Heider has stolen the show. This time Warno has the time and the backing and needs to bring in players who will hit the ground running.

[Rich]

Best : All 3 defenders ( Traore, Young & Ferdinand)
Most Disappointing so far : Barton & SWP
Worst : Bothroyd
Worst loan ever : Puncheon

[SuperHoopNik]

Best: Young, Ferdinand, Traore but if I had to pick 1 then it would be Young
Worst: Gabbidon - Risky defender, Hall proved he's much better than him when he played at Swansea

[Sotonsuperhoop]

Best: Young, Ferdinand, Traore but if I had to pick 1 then it would be Young
Worst: Gabbidon - Risky defender, Hall proved he's much better than him when he played at Swansea

Hall hasn't played against the likes of Chelsea, Villa, Liverpool and Man U so to say he is better than Gabbidon on one avaearge game against lesser opposition is ridiculous

[Jeffro]

Best signing : Young
Worst : Barton

[IsleworthRanger]

Best: Young

Worse: Puncheon though I am sure that was a deal QPR could not have pulled out of as I reckon it wasa Flavio/Bernie signing and he arrived just as Fernades took over so not really the players fault

[MattyRangers]

Best signing : Young
Worst : Barton

So you think Barton been worse than Puncheon Dyer n Bothroyd?

What is your personal vendetta towards him all about?

[QPRDave]

Best : All 3 defenders ( Traore, Young & Ferdinand)
Most Disappointing so far : Barton & SWP
Worst : Bothroyd
Worst loan ever : Puncheon

Rich pretty much agree....but can i remind you of one loan that springs to mind
as worst loan ever.........i give you Tamas Priskin

[EYR]

On paper they look like good signings but to be fair theyve not delivered,Barton and SWP the two big hitters who i expected to really make a difference have flopped. In defence of SWP he's being played everywhere but RW.

Ferdinand,Young and Traore look steady enough but the defence is still very ropey and makes basic mistakes game after game.

Still alot of work to be done in Jan,NW can't afford to get it wrong.

[cujimmy]

So you think Barton been worse than Puncheon Dyer n Bothroyd?

What is your personal vendetta towards him all about?

What's with always picking up on people's opinions as vendettas? If someone has an opinion, that may not conform to the mainstream view, does that mean he must have some kind of ulterior motive?

IMO, I wouldn't have touched Barton with a barge pole. He's a convicted criminal and shouldn't be playing professional football, period! FA fair play and all that... what a load of ********!

He's been average at best for us and hasn't even come close to justifying his wages... and to me that's what it comes down to. Bothroyd over Barton any day!

[cujimmy]

Best: Traore
Worst: Barton. Absolute pony. Rubbish. Get rid.

[MattyRangers]

What's with always picking up on people's opinions as vendettas? If someone has an opinion, that may not conform to the mainstream view, does that mean he must have some kind of ulterior motive?

IMO, I wouldn't have touched Barton with a barge pole. He's a convicted criminal and shouldn't be playing professional football, period! FA fair play and all that... what a load of ********!

He's been average at best for us and hasn't even come close to justifying his wages... and to me that's what it comes down to. Bothroyd over Barton any day!

Each to their own.

[Westbyfleetr]

Worst loan ever Priskin? Possibly you forget Bob Malcolm, but go further back and the golden month that Gus Caesar spent with us still reduces grown men who witnessed it to quivering wrecks. By god, it was the pits.

[Connell10]

Best .young worse dyer