A serious question....

[HammersmithR]

He is morphing into Holloway.

Predictable play. Has his favourites.

No plan A or B.

[QPR Richard]

Totally agree. Mackie works hard but doesn't have the quality. If we're losing with Mackie in the team I'd rather we lost with Taarabt starting instead. At least he makes things happen and has quality about his play.

Like to see bothroyd - Taarabt - SWP behind hiedar on wednesday.

Oh but he does have the 'quality'. It's just a pity it's championship 'quality' and not PL.

[paulmason]

If Mackie has to play, it should be behind the striker, with SWP and Traore on the wings and IMO, Warnock has lost the plot.

[supahoopsaaa]

Oh but he does have the 'quality'. It's just a pity it's championship 'quality' and not PL.

Thanks Richard. Mackie is basic and Warnock is his dad.

[paulmason]

Oh but he does have the 'quality'. It's just a pity it's championship 'quality' and not PL.

Id like to see Bothroyd never play again and I still chuckle that so many on here thought we had the better striker out of Graham, Morrison, Holt and co.

[QPRDave]

Id like to see Bothroyd never play again and I still chuckle that so many on here thought we had the better striker out of Graham, Morrison, Holt and co.

Thats because you are so very clever and the rest of us are not

[QPR Richard]

Id like to see Bothroyd never play again and I still chuckle that so many on here thought we had the better striker out of Graham, Morrison, Holt and co.

I'm not a Jay fan. I dont think he's good enough. But you will find plenty here who say he should play because 'he holds the ball up well'.

His job is to score goals and he doesn't.

[loftlag]

Was it just me ,or did I imagine I saw SWP playing on the left and on the right flanks

[EYR]

How ruthless is Fernandes? Need to start winning games with or without Warnock.

[QPRDave]

Was it just me ,or did I imagine I saw SWP playing on the left and on the right flanks

They switched today i thought too

[ILTA]

Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?

- continuing to play Mackie
- continuing to play SWP out of position
- poor substitutions
- stubborn with tactics

Are we getting found out? No plan B?

Are people starting to question him?

I questioned last week if Mackie was a PL player and I saw nothing today that changed my mind (1 win out of 6 with him starting).
I was hoping NW would put SWP on the right and Taarabt on the left. When Taarabt came on if was SWP out instead og moving him to the right and mackie out. Much more dangerous team being 0-2 down.
I would have liked to see Boyhroyd out instead og Helguson.

[acricketer]

"Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?"

No. Our squad is too weak to compete week in week out. Our best side would survive. We have to invest well in Jan and we'll be fine.

[Naarven Mankey]

I think NW can be stubborn at times. He must surely see the problems but making the necessary changes would be admitting he's got things wrong and would look bad with the players.

So what is Warnock supposed to do eh? Listen to us fans? Half of us love Mackie half of us don't. Half of us adore SWP the rest think hes average. Half of us think Taarabt is god the other half think he's a lazy nonchalant prima donna. Were all arm chair managers these days and yes we'd all do it differently somehow but Warnock has to do it his way. Everyone was happy as Larry last year when we got promotion. Warnock was the bees knees now the same guy making the same decisions doesnt know what hes doing? If he smiles and makes light of a loss to a top team he gets berated by some on here for not showing enough passion yet if he bollooox traore on the field for a stupid mistake he gets berated too. The guy cant win. Did anyone notice his passion when Howard Webb gave a decision against us today. 200% committed to the cause. Give it a rest ffs. Put any manager in charge of the limited squad we have and you're telling me they'd do a better job than what warnock has done. Thought not. Close the door behind you. Stop this stupid bickering and get behind Warnock and the team.

[Ric-Roc]

Agree the squad is limited. Still not an excuse to play the best right winger at the club out of position to accomodate another player who is bringing very little to the table.

Personally yesterday I would of gone with;

------------Cerny----------------

Young-----Connolly----Gabbs-----Hill

SWP------Barton-----Faurlin------Traore

---------------Taarabt---------------

---------------Helguson------------------

[qprbrisbanedivision]

Now personally, i hate Tarbs and dont rate him as good enough for the Prem; and i have posted as such

BUT

we may as well give him a go as the rest of our (very) limited squad aint doing the job.

Like i say, personally i dont rate him but he cant be any worse than Mackie etc.... Put him on, let him play and maybe we'll get a half decent price when we F him off in Jan....

IMO..?