Routledge or DJ J P

[loftlag]

What would posters want to sign Routledge, or Jason Puchion, plus D J Campbell

[Factamondo]

Too be fair dj as he proved a little in the top league last season.....routledge has always failed to deliver regularly in the prem n puncheon nowhere near good enough imho!

[stanistheman]

Campbell for me, as I think he proved last season that he knows how to score goals if chances are created.

[SteveQPR1975]

Dj

[qpr]

DJ Campbell. 13 Premier League goals and QPR fan

[stainrodisalegend]

Can I cheat and say DJ and Routs? Not fussed about Puncheon, sounds like he would be yet another mediocre reserve to add to our collection.

[BennyBoyRs]

Did anyone actually read this?

JP or WR...PLUS DJ Campbell.

Routs for me.

[loftlag]

Did anyone actually read this?

JP or WR...PLUS DJ Campbell.

Routs for me.

That wasn't the question Routs or DJ and JC

[WeAreQPR12]

Routledge but won't happen because the budget will all be spent on dj although we need both. Facto u do talk sh it sometimes. Routs under warnock is a different player and loves our formation.

[superhoop67]

Too be fair dj as he proved a little in the top league last season.....routledge has always failed to deliver regularly in the prem n puncheon nowhere near good enough imho!

that is about right , a fair summing up

[3London]

Puncheon 3 goals in 11 prem appearences
DJ highest scoring english player last season!!!
WR 78 prem appearences 3 goals.

MAybe WR found his level in the championship..i can't see his push and run tactics beating the likes of clichy,gibbs, cole, boswinga evra etc.

[Ginger Ninja]

Funny thing is...everyone is slating puncheon, but in the 11 games he has played in his career at the top level, he has scored 3 more goals than Wayne routledge ever has, and routs has played more than 11 games at the top. So does that not mean that puncheon is more successful than routledge in the premier league? Food for thought.

[WeAreQPR12]

Funny thing is...everyone is slating puncheon, but in the 11 games he has played in his career at the top level, he has scored 3 more goals than Wayne routledge ever has, and routs has played more than 11 games at the top. So does that not mean that puncheon is more successful than routledge in the premier league? Food for thought.

I totally disagree with that post. Wayne is played in a totally different position under warnock and gets into goal scoring positions. Newcastle used him as an out 2 out winger in a 442 system. Blackpool played 433 last season so puncheon could play more central. Harsh judging wayne on his newcastle carrer. He was in and out of the team, mainly out because of barton. Wayne is about pace and sharpness and u don't get that from ocassional start. I also think warnock has improved wayne final ball which was far superior last season. I don't think he gets the credit he deserves and let's face in with regards 2 quality he was a huge improvement on mackie so let's not kid ourselves if we miss out on signing him

[3London]

Years Team Apps† (Gls)†
2001–2005 Crystal Palace 110 (10)
2005–2008 Tottenham Hots 5 (0)
2006 → Portsmouth (loan) 13 (0)
2006–2007 → Fulham (loan) 24 (0)
2008–2009 Aston Villa 2 (0)
2008–2009 → Cardiff City 9 (2)
2009–2010 Queens Park Rangers 49 (6)
2010– Newcastle United 34 (3)
2011 → Queens Park Rangers ( 19 (5)

He does seem to have had the best spells with QPR but hardly prolific..i genuinely don't think he is as good as he thinks he is..but as a crosser of the ball he could be just what our new number 10 needs!

[Stuieang]

Can DJ actually play in the wide role? every1 saying 13 goals last season but that was as striker & id say Bothroyd has that role so Id rather Routledge cause as WeAre put, hes suited our formation interchanging superbly whether its right left or centre & pace was fantastic...but i want DJ too as cover for Bothroyd