Who Is The Better Manager??

[Quaz]

is this the same jim magilton who's ipswich side played us off the park this season?

one game doesn't make a season or a manager...we played stoke off the park last season...who went up?

[Pyrford Ranger]

I'm going to abstain on this vote

[Sam-QPR]

is this also the same jim magilton whos ipswich side finished higher than us this season?

[Quaz]

is this also the same jim magilton whos ipswich side finished higher than us this season?

by 5 points yes...but still not enough to get near play-offs even if he improved us by those 5 points....and didn't he have a fully fit squad and better budget.

[Sam-QPR]

is this the same jim magilton whos ipswitch side scored 62 goals in the league this season?

[Quaz]

is this the same jim magilton whos ipswitch side scored 62 goals in the league this season?

lol...how many did they concede as well....they had a better strike force....we had the better defence....next question.

[qblockpete]

Most important question has to be.

Considering he is loved by Ipswich fans for being a great player.

If the club were confident of getting up next season, why did they not keep him?

[Quaz]

Most important question has to be.

Considering he is loved by Ipswich fans for being a great player.

If the club were confident of getting up next season, why did they not keep him?

spot on mate....

[Mutley]

Most important question has to be.

Considering he is loved by Ipswich fans for being a great player.

If the club were confident of getting up next season, why did they not keep him?

Going by that philosphy, no manager would ever manage again once released by a club.

[Sam-QPR]

"they had a better strike force"

"they had a fully fit team"

they were exactly the points i was hoping somone would say

can ANY manager do well without a decent strikeforce?

we knew vine would be out most of the season. was he replaced?

in jan we knew buzacky was going to be out for the season. was he replaced?

lets face it mistakes were made at board level this season. it wasn't dowie nor sousa. it was the board

has any manager got a chance of being succsessful when they are dismissed before they have started

our squad would be of a similar value to ipswich and at times they played some really nice football last season

some people on here are expecting raneri or sven to be announced. WE ARE A MID TABLE CHAMPIONSHIP TEAM FFS regardless of how much we are being charged. these big name managers are not going to come to us.

is there much difference between magilton and de canio? NO

[Quaz]

Going by that philosphy, no manager would ever manage again once released by a club.

not really....he might do well at some clubs lower down as their expectations would be to just be higher up the table....we want premiership football the same as ipswich...he was deemed not the man to take them up so why should he be better here.

[Quaz]

"they had a better strike force"

"they had a fully fit team"

they were exactly the points i was hoping somone would say

can ANY manager do well without a decent strikeforce?

we knew vine would be out most of the season. was he replaced?

in jan we knew buzacky was going to be out for the season. was he replaced?

lets face it mistakes were made at board level this season. it wasn't dowie nor sousa. it was the board

has any manager got a chance of being succsessful when they are dismissed before they have started

our squad would be of a similar value to ipswich and at times they played some really nice football last season

some people on here are expecting raneri or sven to be announced. WE ARE A MID TABLE CHAMPIONSHIP TEAM FFS regardless of how much we are being charged. these big name managers are not going to come to us.

is there much difference between magilton and de canio? NO

i am not expecting or wanting a big name...stability is what i am looking for and appointing another mid-table manager is not going to give us that as flavio will get rid at christmas.

[Sam-QPR]

appointing another mid-table manager is not going to give us that

we are a mid table team

[Quaz]

we are a mid table team

no sh!t sherlock

if we have ambitions as a club then it has to be a manager that can take us forward...not a manager thats at the same level as we had at the start of the season......dowie & Jm are very similar.....except Dowie had done promotion.

[Mutley]

Why a manger could do better at x club rather than y is dependant on hundreds of factors, imo. Even most of the best managers had failures previously.

All im saying is to give the guy a chance. For many on here, hes a 'dead man walking'.