would you swap mackie for routledge?

[G.T.P]

please vote of youd like to swap our versatile all over the pitch player for the fancy dan stepover king who never ever scores a gaol and gets one assist every blue moon

[Scarlet pimple]

No!!!!!

[stainrodisalegend]

Yes plse. I'd even through in Hogan as a "sweetener" (or leave him out, whatever would make the deal more attractive).

[Morris]

I'd quite like both, so I wont be voting, as its not a 'one or the other' choice, we could have both.

On current form, Mackie and Smith would be starters, but both would have to up their game (especially Mackie) to keep Routledge on the bench.

Lets not forget that Mackie hasn't scored in 12 games for us, although of course I love his work rate and enthusiasm.

[stainrodisalegend]

Just on a point of order, rather than starting random polls shouldn't GTP be busy self-harming at the moment?

[BennyBoyRs]

I'm not fussed, as long as Routs doesn't sign for Baahdiff. They would be absolutely lethel with him and Bellamy either side of Bothroyd or Chopra. They'd be favourites in my book, and that's an honest opinion.

He may not have cracked it in the Prem, but he's superb at this level.

[G.T.P]

2001–2005 Crystal Palace 110 (11)
2005–2008 Tottenham Hotspur 5 (0)
2006 Portsmouth (loan) 13 (0)
2006–2007 Fulham (loan) 24 (0)
2008–2009 Aston Villa 2 (0)
2008–2009 Cardiff City (loan) 9 (2)
2009–2010 Queens Park Rangers 44 (3)
2010– Newcastle United 28 (3)

[Scarlet pimple]

Seems to me Routlidge dont seem to give you loyalty, always chasing the big bucks.....fine player, but not really good enough if we get to the prem...as proven with three clubs.

[BennyBoyRs]

Just on a point of order, rather than starting random polls shouldn't GTP be busy self-harming at the moment?

Still love it!!!

[stainrodisalegend]

Still love it!!!

Hope he doesn't go TOO quiet on us - even I wouldn't want that on my conscience...

[G.T.P]

[stainrodisalegend]

2001–2005 Crystal Palace 110 (11)
2005–2008 Tottenham Hotspur 5 (0)
2006 Portsmouth (loan) 13 (0)
2006–2007 Fulham (loan) 24 (0)
2008–2009 Aston Villa 2 (0)
2008–2009 Cardiff City (loan) 9 (2)
2009–2010 Queens Park Rangers 44 (3)
2010– Newcastle United 28 (3)

Be interesting how many assists he has been credited with.

[BennyBoyRs]

Yeah, I don't wish that on anyone...Bless.

[sirpiechucker]

I'm not fussed, as long as Routs doesn't sign for Baahdiff. They would be absolutely lethel with him and Bellamy either side of Bothroyd or Chopra. They'd be favourites in my book, and that's an honest opinion.

He may not have cracked it in the Prem, but he's superb at this level.

Arguably though it would make them defensively weaker because at least Burke tracks back and offensively weaker because Burke scores goals whereas Routledge's record in front of goal is poor.

[Chalet1882]

im sorry but ive got to say again routledge is a journeyman who is lazy and does the same thing too often