Jamie mackie is this a joke

[rmj1982]

Played 35 games this season goals scored 7 here we go again.

[ollyhoops]

I'm 50/50 on him, although bear in mind he played in a poor Plymouth side.

[W12_Ranger]

With all due respect how often have you seen the lad play live to make a fair assessment on his ability as a footballer.

We can all look at Wikipedia.

[Morris]

Mackie is a very good player.

[EYR]

Billy Sharp didnt pull up any trees at Sheff Utd but look at the success hes had at Donny,no reason Mackie cant do the same.

[stainrodisalegend]

reserve judgement. might well be an improvement on vine, agyman, etc (not hard) but even if he is a revelation we will also need strikers of higher calibre if we are to challenge next season.

[qblockpete]

Problem is when players like Steve Howard or DJ Campbell are mentioned they are not good enough. What do we expect?

have to say though I am underwhelmed over Mackie.

[ollyhoops]

Problem is when players like Steve Howard or DJ Campbell are mentioned they are not good enough. What do we expect?

have to say though I am underwhelmed over Mackie.

Normally your optimistic?

[BennyBoyRs]

It's only because Pete hadn't heard of him. He didn't even know who Jobi McAnuff was when I called him. I swear on my life.

Mackie is a very good player, that's all I can say. I can't make you all believe me, so we'll have to wait and see. Oh, and Pete hadn't heard of Buzz either by the way. He told me the rumour on the boat en route to Charlton just before he signed. Didn't have a clue so I bought up Buzz's goal against us in that midweek fixture. It just goes to show...just because you've not heard of them, doesn't mean their no good ;)

[W12_Ranger]

Isn't it about how these players fit into a team and formation and not about their stats on Wikipedia?

[qblockpete]

Bennyboyr's please lets get it right.

I knew who Job Mcanuff was, i just thought he was at reading

[BennyBoyRs]

Bennyboyr's please lets get it right.

I knew who Job Mcanuff was, i just thought he was at reading

You lying toe rag. I had to explain who he was and what position. I spelt his name out, you googled him and said he was at Reading. Come on mate...hands up!!!

[ollyhoops]

Jobi Notgoodenough.... :-s

[Rebel R's]

obviously NW rates him,so we will have to see,cant be any worse than Vine or Agymang,but we now need 2 QUALITY strikers,starting with Hooper.

[Fawny]

FFS How many times do I have to say this:

WE HAVE A PROPER MANAGER. TRUST HIM!!

Why do people think they know better than Neil Warnock?