Assessment on Paladini from Clive Whittingham /merged thread/

[Sharpy]

I thought this was about GP ?

[ScottJones]

I thought this was about GP ?

See my earlier post.

I'm getting pished off with things getting dragged all over the shop.

[paulmason]

Sousa, Magilton and Hart picked/pick their own teams.

There is no way in gods earth Hart picked the team against Sheffield Utd at home. That was a a board room test tube team selection.

Hart may not be classed the best manager in the world, but he has a brain and would not play Simpson on the right wing, Routledge on the left wing and Taarabt up front.

[Rsonist]

sorry but what is there other than paranoia to suggest that suggests the team for the west brom and sheffield united games wasn't picked by bircham and gallen?

[qblockpete]

He kept the same team/formation that almost got us victory against WBA..

As regards to Sharpy's commenst, maybe it should have been written only 2 months ago, as fans have short memories. It wasn't written then, because it wouldn't have a got responses/

[Rsonist]

furthermore if hart has this big common sense brain why is he stubbornly insisting on a diamond formation with an eleven without a proper screening midfielder and at least one out and out winger?

[Rsonist]

without a defensive midfielder and WITH one out and out winger, i meant to say.

[Bernie's Barnet]

Bernies

I had a look at my posts from the old forum and you'l see it was after Norwich, I was expressing my real concerns.

I had a look at your post from last week and you said up until then, no one supported Sousa more. Now you're saying you always thought he was rubbish.

Which is it?

[Bernie's Barnet]

The only real time he did that was under De Canio..First January period

As in the case of Faurlin he will ask the manager to take a look at him.

Dowie unfortuntaely was undermined by Parejo, DE Carmine etc, but it is well documented they are because of Flavio's contacts at respective clubs real Madrid and Fiorentina

Sousa, Magilton and Hart picked/pick their own teams .

You only have to look at Lopez who was clearly a Sousa player and Borrowdale being shipped out to Brighton, to know he made all the player decisions

Borrowdale arrived on loan and was made perm while Sousa was here, was that his decision?

Helguson arrived on loan and was made perm while Sousa was here, was that his decision? Did Sousa insist on signing Helguson despite medical advice?

[QPRMendoza]

Can I suggest something?

Lets not move this into a slagging off war? Clive is well respected and well respected for a reason....lets face it ALL OF US thought the footy under sousa was frigging sh/te..clive did, you did, i did, every fan i know did..the debate is how he was booted/should he have been booted. The debate is not our opinions on what we had to endure watching his team.

This is a conversation about GP (who i consider a friend)..not about Sousa, not about Clive and not about any other individual.

it has nothing to do with Sousa.

Just my opinion like.

I thought this was about GP ?

See my earlier post.

I'm getting pished off with things getting dragged all over the shop.

Sorry Scott I don't understand what you mean. In your erlier post you said this is a converstaion about GP.:confused:

[Bernie's Barnet]

We have sang managers names at games but the Sousa one was the hardest to get going, why was this and the only time we got this going was away at Cardiff... we Rangers fans didn't stop for a good 20 to 30 minutes that game and at home it didn't work so why was this and why didn't the fans want to sing for Sousa?

Even Gigi, Dowie & Magilton had more fans singing he's name.

Obviously, because the singer in chief thought Sousa was rubbish from the outset.

[ScottJones]

Sorry Scott I don't understand what you mean. In your erlier post you said this is a converstaion about GP.:confused:

Sorry, I am mate, maybe i wasnt clear. My latter comment was about threads getting taken in different directions..as this one has by it being twisted to be a convo about sousa..just trying to keep it on track.

[Bernie's Barnet]

Sorry, I am mate, maybe i wasnt clear. My latter comment was about threads getting taken in different directions..as this one has by it being twisted to be a convo about sousa..just trying to keep it on track.

Well there's only one person who twisted it in Sousa's direction isn't there?

[QPRMendoza]

Sorry, I am mate, maybe i wasnt clear. My latter comment was about threads getting taken in different directions..as this one has by it being twisted to be a convo about sousa..just trying to keep it on track.

Thanks for clearing that up - been far too much hijacking recently from both sides!

[w3r]

Sorry, I am mate, maybe i wasnt clear. My latter comment was about threads getting taken in different directions..as this one has by it being twisted to be a convo about sousa..just trying to keep it on track.

Well can you have a quick word with your buddy Pete so that he knows.