Of The "Two" Who Would You Keep??

[qblockpete]

which one of the two?

[Rieger]

Vine will win this easily. But they both bring different advantages.

[writtler]

Running around like a headless chicken is an advantage?

[stainrodisalegend]

Southampton clearly wants Agypants. Who wants Vine?

I like Vine but not sure where he fits in. If we brought in two strikers WHO SCORE GOALS I would be sad to lose Vine but think I'd get over it pretty quickly.

[Gtleighsr3]

Aggy is an impact sub ,hes strong ,fast,and can hold a ball up.all which Vine isnt.Vine can hit a barn door at 2ft though.

Still voted PA

[WeAreQPR12]

I would start both against sheff wed.

[Robsondinho]

Tough call....doubt very much Vine would reach his top level again.

[Bluehoop]

Vine all day long, but for now we should keep both as Pat does give us a pace option last 15 mins to hit sides on the break. Needless to say if we need to ship one out to get one in I will not complain

[WeAreQPR12]

Tough call....doubt very much Vine would reach his top level again.

I disagree.
Definate signs of the old Vine in glimpses.
To talented to ship out as I think with a run of games we will see the best of him. I think he has been very unlucky infront of goal and deserves a chance

[kingo]

I disagree.
Definate signs of the old Vine in glimpses.
To talented to ship out as I think with a run of games we will see the best of him. I think he has been very unlucky infront of goal and deserves a chance

Would have been a real tonic for him if Speroni hadn't got a hand to his shot on Tuesday. I thought both mixed things up on Tuesday but still don't think we have seen the old RW. We need some one with Dave's height but better infront of goal.

[Youvebeenrangered]

For me its a very tuff choice! Agyemang is a better impact sub because he is fast and strong, he's a defenders nightmare for the last 15 minutes of a game!!

I like vine, he would score more than agyemang, he's clearly favoured over agyemang by the management staff, he has been given chances!!! But has failed to take them!

Really tuff one but id go Vine...

[oldhoop]

I will be very interested to hear what BennyBoy has to say about this!!!

However I just can't imagine why anyone would choose "Dave" over Rowan.

Vine is a class player in comparison to Aggy and is still getting back to match sharpness. I can see him starting if Buz, Adel or Routledge get injured or suspended.

[stanistheman]

Vine would be my choice too.

He has only scored 1 this season, but how many of his shots have hit the woodwork or brought out good saves, cleared off the line?

I can think of 3 hitting the woodwork, at least 3 fine saves and 1 off the line.

With a bit of luck, it could have easily been at least 6 goals scored this season, and we wouldn't even be having this debate.

[QPR1234]

depends imo agyemang has come on now and played with some tempo and desire.. which we havent seen in ages.

vine has more quality but still isnt back to his former self.. still abit lazy

[Bluehoop]

Would have been a real tonic for him if Speroni hadn't got a hand to his shot on Tuesday. I thought both mixed things up on Tuesday but still don't think we have seen the old RW. We need some one with Dave's height but better infront of goal.

Not just better in front of goal though, he would need to be much better with his head as Pat is a liability in the air.