Anyone see....

[LoftusRoadLad]

What that was about ?

[West Acton]

Pretty stupid by Robinson

[Tarbie]

Pretty stupid by Robinson

Can the league take retrospective action from footage like this, or does it need to be caught on TV cameras?

[West Acton]

Not sure mate reckon they can use any evidence if it’s available

[Tarbie]

Not sure mate reckon they can use any evidence if it’s available

Hope you are wrong on that mate. Whether he connected or not, that's a straight red. Would be a 3 game ban if there was to be retrospective action.

[Joe90]

Doesn't look like he actually hit him in the face or punched him. I think it was gentle elbow to the chest and as always the player made a meal of it. Also, Jota may have stamped on him...watch the video again.

[Tarbie]

Doesn't look like he actually hit him in the face or punched him. I think it was gentle elbow to the chest and as always the player made a meal of it. Also, Jota may have stamped on him...watch the video again.

Provocation won't hold much weight with the FA mate. Robinson has got up, casually wandered over and raised his hand to Jota. Has to be a red card if the officials see the incident!

[Northolt_Rs]

Provocation won't hold much weight with the FA mate. Robinson has got up, casually wandered over and raised his hand to Jota. Has to be a red card if the officials see the incident!

Jota quite clearly stamps on Robbo.....if that isn’t a red card what is?

[stan_bowles]

Can the league take retrospective action from footage like this, or does it need to be caught on TV cameras?

Who the #### goes to football to film a game?.

[Tarbie]

Jota quite clearly stamps on Robbo.....if that isn’t a red card what is?

Clearly I'm not seeing what you're seeing mate. Looks to me like Jota has clipped Robinsons heel as they are both running back, Robinson has fallen, Jota has hurdled him and maybe trod on his hand in doing so. I don't see any type of intentional stamp there.

The problem with Robinsons response is he gets up, walks away from the direction play is heading over to Jota and raises his hand to him. It's premeditated and calculated, there is no argument that it happened during the run of play or in the heat of the moment. Robinson has got up and casually wandered over before taking a swing. That's how it would be judged if there was retrospective action, and I'm 100% sure he would get a 3 game ban.

[WeAreQPR12]

OK 1stly jack was right to retaliate off the ball. I am glad he would as I bet jota was up to no good. 2ndly it used to happen in football all the time. Adams and keown were masters out trending on feet, little punches etc it's call gamesmanship however cameras are everywhere in premier league games these days and they are stopping this art of defending. With regards to someone's mobile footage they can't do a thing about it so you can all relax and I suggest if you want to film a work colleague because he is not following company rules etc then don't as it's an offence for a written warning. You cant film anyone in the work place as it invades their privacy. It happened where I am and no I wasn't either party but I am glad the grass got a written warning

[Shania]

He can get a ban for this, sadly..A stupid reaction from Robinson.

[WeAreQPR12]

He can get a ban for this, sadly..A stupid reaction from Robinson.

No he can't and that's a fact, different completely if it's a tv camera

[Tarbie]

No he can't and that's a fact, different completely if it's a tv camera

But do we know for sure it hasn't been caught by a TV camera?

[Shania]

[QUOTE=Tarbie;1679386[B]]But do we know for sure it hasn't been caught by a TV camera?[/[/B]QUOTE]

No. I should believe that is the problem.