Hall or ?

[LoftusRoadLad]

Perch-------Ned------Lynch-------Bidwell

Lots say Hall ain't no midfielder. I agree, but would you still have him in place of either the other 2 ?

[maidstone_hoop]

Hall is first choice cb for me!

I'd personally play hall and lynch week in week out! It's Ned we got to move on!

[rodman]

Hall is first choice cb for me!

I'd personally play hall and lynch week in week out! It's Ned we got to move on!

this a thousand times over!

[corbray]

Hall is first choice cb for me!

I'd personally play hall and lynch week in week out! It's Ned we got to move on!

This!! Ned has more bad games than good games for us, so much so that people call him nervous ned!
Other teams rate him so much more highly than he actually is and we should take advantage of that and sell him imo, i reckon we'd get 4 million for him easily! Bring clint in as cover and a coach and spend 4m on a new striker or two

[Ginger Ninja]

Hall for Ned imo. Hall is wasted at CM and is a far better CB than Ned.

[West Acton]

Agree with above. He's a CB and should play there. Actually think it's a sign of Holloway bottling making a tough decision as to play Hall CB needs to drop one of Ned or Lynch so instead of doing that play Hall Midfield as he did with Palmer and Rose

[bakes8]

This!! Ned has more bad games than good games for us, so much so that people call him nervous ned!
Other teams rate him so much more highly than he actually is and we should take advantage of that and sell him imo, i reckon we'd get 4 million for him easily! Bring clint in as cover and a coach and spend 4m on a new striker or two

I honestly think there is not a team in the Cosmos that would pay £4m for Onuoha. Would love to be wrong tho.

[dogsrrs]

It's always difficult to keep a clean sheet when you have no threat up front and the last 2 games we have conceded a goal a game with Hall in m/f , a few good opinions rated him
M O M against Villa seems hard to knock him as a m/f player

[SpongeParr]

I actually quite like Hall in midfield. Dier was a centre back and now he is not seen as one.

[jmelanie]

How long a contract does Ned have?

[Pinkie]

Agree with above. He's a CB and should play there. Actually think it's a sign of Holloway bottling making a tough decision as to play Hall CB needs to drop one of Ned or Lynch so instead of doing that play Hall Midfield as he did with Palmer and Rose

I honestly believe halls really good in midfield and will get better the more he plays, hes got good technique aswell as winning headers, think ollies made a good call, but also rate hall as a cb aswell!

[davieqpr]

No way 'let it bounce first' Ned should be in first team.But every manager adapts tactics to shoehorn him in.

[cross it Dave]

Hall is first choice cb for me!

I'd personally play hall and lynch week in week out! It's Ned we got to move on!

I could not agree more

[LoftusRoadLad]

How about when Caulker is fit ? Seems we've forgot about him !

[West Acton]

I honestly believe halls really good in midfield and will get better the more he plays, hes got good technique aswell as winning headers, think ollies made a good call, but also rate hall as a cb aswell!

Time will tell Pinksey but when you have CM sitting on bench don't make an awful lot of sense to me but perhaps he sees something I don't but personally not for me