Alex Smithies how good

[Timmy the Doc]

One of the best penalty stoppers in the country and very good in 1 v 1 situations.

[SuperHoopNik]

Keep him and get rid of Chery and Ned, Caulker, Sandro.

One way ticket to league 1 hahaha

[TimPR78]

Derby want 4 mill for their reserve, 33 year old keeper.... So Smithies must be worth, well a lot!

[James1979]

We do also have a decent back-up. Very strong in goalie position. Shame about rest of squad

[MattyRangers]

Smithies is a chap. Proper keeper.

[jmelanie]

If the club were thinking of selling him, wouldn't they be playing Ingram?

[nanocopic]

If the club were thinking of selling him, wouldn't they be playing Ingram?

No, I imagine they would sell him when the right price turns up but they are under no need to sell otherwise so may as we'll keep him. We would have finished a few places higher last year had Smithies played from the start.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Villa reported to be buying Smithies for 4 million.

[Brian Wilson]

Villa reported to be buying Smithies for 4 million.

Please Kev, It's Christmas

[West Acton]

They have rough would tell them put £2mil on it or some serious add ons. In today's market £4mil is a steal and cheap

[corbray]

No way smithies is worth way more than 4m and if we sold him for 4m we may as well give up

[The General]

I reckon 10 million

Best since Seaman

[The General]

Think he will be a future england keeper

massive potential.

[corbray]

I reckon 10 million

Best since Seaman

Given how crazy transfer fees have been over the past couple of years 10m should be more than fair!
Not just saying this as i'm a qpr fan but imo he's easily one of the top keepers in the country, more than capable of being a prem player and a future england keeper

[rodman]

If TF sanctions the sale of Smithies then he can do one.

Always supported TF 100% right up until he appointed Holloway.
Massive mistake and selling our only decent player would be an even bigger mistake.

Probably only paper talk anyway.