Newcastle want Caulker?

[Kevin Mcleod]

That's what I mean, just keep staying out on loan cos nobody will want to pay any money for them.

[qpr4life]

That's what I mean, just keep staying out on loan cos nobody will want to pay any money for them.

Well, that's good for us...

1. We got a fee of nearly up to £2million pounds for Caulker alone this year.
2. Caulkers wages are paid for in full...

Good business.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Well, that's good for us...

1. We got a fee of nearly up to £2million pounds for Caulker alone this year.
2. Caulkers wages are paid for in full...

Good business.

Selling would be much much better though, to free some funds for jfh to buy more burton players.

[qpr4life]

Selling would be much much better though, to free some funds for jfh to buy more burton players.

Yep, selling is key, but as you saw last year it was hard to shift for the right fee etc etc.... IF he goes out on loan and we get another fee for him we've done well IMO.

[Hertford Hoop]

Didn't Corker play up front for the Scousers in a game or 2? Could be a handy option for us

[nasser95]

How people think Caulker is worth less than 5/6 mil is beyond me in the current market. You seen how much sh 1te british players are going for? 6mil is a good start for a player like him. Physically a solid defender but technically lost completely, he's worth a lot because of his physique (something you can't really teach a defender). British players are so overinflated that Caulker for 6 mil is considered an ok deal to many outside this club.

[qpr4life]

How people think Caulker is worth less than 5/6 mil is beyond me in the current market. You seen how much sh 1te british players are going for? 6mil is a good start for a player like him. Physically a solid defender but technically lost completely, he's worth a lot because of his physique (something you can't really teach a defender). British players are so overinflated that Caulker for 6 mil is considered an ok deal to many outside this club.

Given he was bought for a reported £8million and that he now only has 2 years left on his current deal, I would say he's probably only going to get £3million MAX. He isn't setting any records or stats that suggests he worth anymore than that.... otherwise we would be begging to keep the lad?

To add the guy has had a disaster season, playing 6 games on loan at two teams.. It says it all really.

[Greg1882]

Hahahahahaha, the only club funnier than that shambles would be villa. Bite their hands off

[Shepherds Mush]

How people think Caulker is worth less than 5/6 mil is beyond me in the current market. You seen how much sh 1te british players are going for?.

Well if Kieran Trippier can go from Burnley to Spurs for £3.5m while he is on a 3 year contract with Burnley, then yeah our superstar CB who has failed to get a first team place at 2 PL clubs (and 1 with a CB shortage) should easily be £6m +

[Greg1882]

Well if Kieran Trippier can go from Burnley to Spurs for £3.5m while he is on a 3 year contract with Burnley, then yeah our superstar CB who has failed to get a first team place at 2 PL clubs (and 1 with a CB shortage) should easily be £6m +

Exactly. Some people are utterly deluded in what they think our players are worth. Caulker has repeatedly failed at the top level, has had off the field issues and is completely bang average yet figures of 5/6 million are being bandied about. Just because we had our pants pulled down don't expect other clubs to do the same. He's not very good. I'd accept a couple of million and another overrated loser off the wage bill

[FurtiveFox]

Exactly. Some people are utterly deluded in what they think our players are worth. Caulker has repeatedly failed at the top level, has had off the field issues and is completely bang average yet figures of 5/6 million are being bandied about. Just because we had our pants pulled down don't expect other clubs to do the same. He's not very good. I'd accept a couple of million and another overrated loser off the wage bill

Yep, precisely this. Wouldn't be averse to him staying and settling down, could be an asset. However he has failed at his last three clubs including us so his stock not particularly high.

[maidstone_hoop]

I know I'm firmly in the minority here on this subject maybe on my own in fact but I actually wouldn't mind keeping caulker and playing him alongside Hall.

Think they have the potential to be one of the best pairings in the league.

[Shepherds Mush]

I know I'm firmly in the minority here on this subject maybe on my own in fact but I actually wouldn't mind keeping caulker and playing him alongside Hall.

Think they have the potential to be one of the best pairings in the league.

Caulker is a paper player - only place he looks good.

[hal9thou]

to free some funds for jfh to buy more burton players.

glad you haven't lost your sense of humour Kev...... ;)

[Ginger Ninja]

I know I'm firmly in the minority here on this subject maybe on my own in fact but I actually wouldn't mind keeping caulker and playing him alongside Hall.

Think they have the potential to be one of the best pairings in the league.

I'm with you on that. Caulker in the Premier League is utter pony imo. But in the Championship? Could be handy, provided he WANTS to play. Which i doubt.