Strange smell coming from Loftus Road.

[Milney]

I was at Swindon v Blackpool and Doughty was very average. Was expecting good things after his two goals the previous week but he offered no attacking threat and gave the ball away on numerous occasions. I am not a fan of Tozer but Doughty is not the solution, yet.

[West Acton]

I was at Swindon v Blackpool and Doughty was very average. Was expecting good things after his two goals the previous week but he offered no attacking threat and gave the ball away on numerous occasions. I am not a fan of Tozer but Doughty is not the solution, yet.

No no no mate so many on here have decided he's the future and will transform us don't ruin the dream

[Alanwycombe]

No no no mate so many on here have decided he's the future and will transform us don't ruin the dream

To borrow a phrase from an old song 'if he was going to come he'd have been here by now'.

[West Acton]

Agree been at club for what six years already 23years old if he was going to break in he would have done so by now

[Martinmalta]

Agree been at club for what six years already 23years old if he was going to break in he would have done so by now

Kind of agree, however, how many youngsters were given a chance in these last four or five years?

[upperloft]

No no no mate so many on here have decided he's the future and will transform us don't ruin the dream

What do you reckon then west? Keep with Toszer think Oscar Gobern will soon be fit.

[Hubble]

I was at Swindon v Blackpool and Doughty was very average. Was expecting good things after his two goals the previous week but he offered no attacking threat and gave the ball away on numerous occasions. I am not a fan of Tozer but Doughty is not the solution, yet.

By the same token, I saw him at Huddersfield where we won away and kept a clean sheet and he was tenacious in defence, ran all the game, proved a formidable barrier alongside Faurlin and passed well, trying to pass forward as often as he could. And that's a division higher. So we have to take a balanced view from more than one game. From what I've seen, he's a better option than Toszer, simple as that.

[West Acton]

What do you reckon then west? Keep with Toszer think Oscar Gobern will soon be fit.

No none of them are up to it so ship them out instead of wasting a wage on them and put money towards decent replacement. I know we want to bring youth players through I'm like everyone else I want that but they need to be of the right standard and quality or what's the point.

Doughty is the latest some demand for no other reason then he's through the ranks but if you have seen him play its clear as day he's not up to it regardless of how much we may want him to be. Now comley the few times I have seen him looks like he has something about him and that's where our time and efforts should be placed

If we were to bring someone in I would try and get Birdcutt if Brighton don't go up

[Hubble]

No none of them are up to it so ship them out instead of wasting a wage on them and put money towards decent replacement. I know we want to bring youth players through I'm like everyone else I want that but they need to be of the right standard and quality or what's the point.

Doughty is the latest some demand for no other reason then he's through the ranks but if you have seen him play its clear as day he's not up to it regardless of how much we may want him to be. Now comley the few times I have seen him looks like he has something about him and that's where our time and efforts should be placed

If we were to bring someone in I would try and get Birdcutt if Brighton don't go up

See my post above.

[Stanley]

Now Comley, the few times I have seen him looks like he has something about him and that's where our time and efforts should be placed

Agree with that. I remember Charlie Austin singing his praises too.

[West Acton]

See my post above.

Did mate suppose we all look for different things. For me he dont lack heart or an engine but that's not enough in my book. Accept you may see positives and attributes I don't

[dogsrrs]

Kind of agree, however, how many youngsters were given a chance in these last four or five years?

But Marty how many have gone on at other clubs and come up trumps , got to agree with Westy that Comely is the only one that looks like he could break the mould , think he's back this week I hope JFH takes a good look at him

[Milney]

I was also at huddersfield game and agree he looked the business. Also thought he played well in the cup game against Carlisle in what was a very poor QPR performance. But yesterday he was not good enough for a Swindon side that dominated the game. I had a very close eye on him yesterday as I had Breton Swindon winning 2-1 with Doughty scoring the last goal. With the score at 1-1 at half time thought I had a chance of winning over a ton but he got nowhere near the ball in the attacking third.