Borini or Defoe

[w12dave]

Borini is 23, should we get Defoe he's will only play for QPR for a 2 or 3 years max so I rather borini who is a good player and can improve at QPR being one of our main player for many years

[hh9]

Borini for me, we need to build for the future (Defoe would have been a typicl signing from the Hughes area).

[Hoop-du-Jour]

Still not woke up then

Haha!

[chalbury37]

I think the reason we made a bid for borini was defoes wage demands, I might be wrong but it makes sense

[West Acton]

Defoe

[Del]

Happy with either.

I'm liking the young side we have amassed though and the prospect of a group playing togetther and improving as a team is mouthwatering, and for that aspect Borini would be preferable, but Defoe injury aside would get goals.

[maverick69]

Defoe will bang in goals for fun. A like-for-like replacement for Remy.

The other lad must one for the future though. The Sunderland fans are committing Hari-Kiri en-mass over his potential move to us......... Lol.

[alanfullerqpr]

I want both

Agree both and thats 4 strikers with Vargas on the wing meaning no Lennon or Townsend

[chalbury37]

Just a thought could defoe have been in the back of HR land rover when he shot past the sky cameras

[MYU]

Just a thought could defoe have been in the back of HR land rover when he shot past the sky cameras

I thought something was going on because he didn't drive past, he flew past.

If we sign Borini, then we won't get Defoe.

[surrey_hoop]

You've got to look at this from a business perspective - Borini, if he finds form and scores goals in the PL, would increase in value by maybe another £3-4m next summer. Defoe on the other hand could score 10-15 goals this season and still not be worth much more than whatever we would be preapred to buy him for. TF has said all along that he wants players who will hold or increase their value, and for me Borini fits that bill. Yes, £10-13m is a lot, but the guy has another 1-2 years to improve, and then another 3-4 years in his prime. Add the lower wages into the equation, and for me Borini just makes more sense.

[Ed the Ball]

Borini please, we don't need another mercenary like Defoe

[chalbury37]

I wonder where harry was shooting off to just now on sky??

[hal9thou]

You can not get away from Borini's dreadful ratio wherever he has been in the prem.

[surrey_hoop]

You can not get away from Borini's dreadful ratio wherever he has been in the prem.

My God, you really have got a cob on about Borini haven't you? I wouldn't necessarily call a goal every 4.5 games (as he did with Sunderland) "dreadful". He never even got a chance at Liverpool, so you can't factor that into your argument.