Caroll and Benajoun

[Shania]

Both of them had a good game today. Very effective in their play. Credit when credit is due,etc..

[Brightsparx]

Yossi was good best I have seen of him

[Shania]

Yep, agreed. Could be a player who can be valuable for us in the Play-Offs.

[californiahoop]

He also played very well against Wigan, the sending off broke his fitness drive.

[Shania]

That is correct, Californiahoop.
Should we offer him a new contract? I would say yes.

[Greg1882]

Agree that he's played well on a handful of occasions and was great today but offer him a new contract ? At his age ? Isn't the dream to move forward as a club and mould a team that could play together for a few years rather than a constant high turnover of old players on a last pay deal ? New contract ? No ta

[West Acton]

The more I see of a fit Yossi the more I like him shame we have not got more game time out of him

[JuniorPower]

At this stage there's no room for anymore criticism, let's just get behind the lads!

[Greg1882]

At this stage there's no room for anymore criticism, let's just get behind the lads!

I didn't critisise anyone I just stated that to offer a new contract to a 30 something player who's only really had a handful of games that he's played well in would be ridiculous . I said I thought he was great today and has been on a few occasions . If just like to see the club move forward with younger hungry players . That's not really a criticism is it ?

[Fordy]

Tommy Carroll was quality today. 2 assists? Think that's 3 in 3 games. I know a lot of people seem to slate him quite a lot but I'd like to sign him on a perm if possible. This is his first full season playing regularly, will only get better. Thought he was more positive today passing forward more. Played an absolute worldy reverse ball forgot to who now but was real class.

[Kevin Mcleod]

add ravel, and zamora, oh and hoilett had his best game for us imho. Superb performance, dodgy defence at set pieces aside. Bet it really peed a few of the harry haters off, especially with it coming together at the right time as well. Need to push in and perform like that till season end, and the miracle can happen.

[Brightsparx]

Agreed kev. Don't get beat now rest of season were up

[Kevin Mcleod]

Agreed kev. Don't get beat now rest of season were up

Play like that every game and tighten up on those poxy dead ball defending errors and we really could do it mate.

[Shania]

Tommy Carroll was quality today. 2 assists? Think that's 3 in 3 games. I know a lot of people seem to slate him quite a lot but I'd like to sign him on a perm if possible. This is his first full season playing regularly, will only get better. Thought he was more positive today passing forward more. Played an absolute worldy reverse ball forgot to who now but was real class.

Excatly. And he did shoot aswell. I would also like to see him given a contract. His interplay with Hoilett, Benayoun and Ravel was excellent. If we chose not to opt for his signature, it is back to square one regarding chasing young players.
Just my opinion.

[Brightsparx]

Agreed mate. Every time give a free kick or corner away was on edge of seat. That can't go on. Noticed Harry and his puppet both said were small today??? Didn't notice it before Xmas. Had carrol on edge of six yard box today. Should be on post never attacks and wins headers. Stick Charlie on edge. Let them off today as they were a big side so Charlie had to mark but we need to step up