Not a huge fan of Monsieur Barton but...

[NW_Hoopz]

Injuries plain and simple we got them from January and it decimated us. Mind you I am not a HR fan in anyway, never liked him really but without those injuries we would have gone up without doubt.

We have scraped out our wins & draws all season, can anyone say they have honesty left a game excited by the dross they've just watched ?

That was before injuries too !

[West London is Rss]

Injuries plain and simple we got them from January and it decimated us. Mind you I am not a HR fan in anyway, never liked him really but without those injuries we would have gone up without doubt.

A few fans still say injuries but I just cant accept that.. not after watching them even when our players were fit.. it still weren't great, Charlie just scored our goals to bail us out.
Burnley have had Ings out and now Vokes, yet they still continue to win and keep clean sheets with a smaller, cheaper, less talented squad.. No excuses IMO

[Del]

Injuries plain and simple we got them from January and it decimated us. Mind you I am not a HR fan in anyway, never liked him really but without those injuries we would have gone up without doubt.

Everyone gets injuries..... who put together the insufficient and unbalanced squad with huge financial backing for this level???? That would be Harry.


Look at who's going up instead of us, Burnley. In the summer they lost Austin to us, yet find two goal machines. Ings then got injured for a month ann then recently volkes out for the season, but they still pick up wins.

[West London is Rss]

Everyone gets injuries..... who put together the insufficient and unbalanced squad with huge financial backing for this level???? That would be Harry.


Look at who's going up instead of us, Burnley. In the summer they lost Austin to us, yet find two goal machines. Ings then got injured for a month ann then recently volkes out for the season, but they still pick up wins.

amazing aint it that there are some fans out there still looking for an excuse to defend redknapp... I would guess that these fans haven't been regulars to games this season

[Del]

amazing aint it that there are some fans out there still looking for an excuse to defend redknapp... I would guess that these fans haven't been regulars to games this season

Nothing to do with seeing games, i havenet been able to get to any games htis season for various reasons, yet let the facts dictate my opinion, which is that he is useless. There are far too many fans who refuse to accept facts and look at everything through their Redknapp tinted sunglasses.

[Kevin Mcleod]

not being controversial, but people screaming and shouting to get the manager out etc on forums that never ever go to a game, can they have the same opinion on say for instance 'millwall', cos they dont ever go there either. Its just all a bit cloudy to my brain,

[West London is Rss]

IMO to grasp the full picture of the team and manager etc etc. You have to physically sit and watch the game from 0-90 minutes.

[Del]

not being controversial, but people screaming and shouting to get the manager out etc on forums that never ever go to a game, can they have the same opinion on say for instance 'millwall', cos they dont ever go there either. Its just all a bit cloudy to my brain,

Obviously not, unless they follow everything to do with Millwall, watch extended highlights of every game highlighting countless failings, interact on their forums absorbing feedback of others, listen to the interviews and excuses from the staff and digest all relevant facts and figures, no.

Not going to games doesnt mean people can't evaluate a situation. If people start making bold statements without any substence to back up their opinions or comments, then that's different.

[Nick]

So everyone on here who can't get to the game's can't have an opinion on qpr?

[West London is Rss]

So everyone on here who can't get to the game's can't have an opinion on qpr?

Who has said they 'cant have an opinion'.. ive said you cant grab sense of the FULL situation as someone who goes to every game can.

[Nick]

Who has said they 'cant have an opinion'.. ive said you cant grab sense of the FULL situation as someone who goes to every game can.

Oh right my bad. So the one's who can't go to the game's can have an opinion about the match but it's more than likely going to be wrong? Even though iv said Redkanpps tactics are $hit, Redknapps formation is $hit and our overall performances have been $hit???

[QPReuge]

Who has said they 'cant have an opinion'.. ive said you cant grab sense of the FULL situation as someone who goes to every game can.

Have to disagree. Going to every game doesn't necessarily mean your knowledge/insight is automatically better than someone who goes to the occasional game or none at all for that matter. There's enough coverage in the press etc along with hard stats and facts which anyone can avail themselves to. In some ways not being in the thick of it at every game, along with the mob mentality that can influence some fans opinion, allows a person to make a more informed judgement.
I've seen some proper planks down at loftus road over the years and its clear no matter how many games they go to, they'll never have a scooby about what's happening on the pitch in terms of tactics etc.

[West London is Rss]

Have to disagree. Going to every game doesn't necessarily mean your knowledge/insight is automatically better than someone who goes to the occasional game or none at all for that matter. There's enough coverage in the press etc along with hard stats and facts which anyone can avail themselves to. In some ways not being in the thick of it at every game, along with the mob mentality that can influence some fans opinion, allows a person to make a more informed judgement.
I've seen some proper planks down at loftus road over the years and its clear no matter how many games they go to, they'll never have a scooby about what's happening on the pitch in terms of tactics etc.

Sort of agree with basically it depends on if you know anything about football haha.. so lets go with 2 people that understand football and certain formations.
The one that goes to all the live games will have a better picture of the dire style and management as opposed to the one who watches the odd game on TV or on a stream.

Me included, when I have missed games.. I don't know the full story so to speak, because I wasn't there. I watched the highlights etc but still wouldn't get the full grasp unless I was there

[Nick]

Hey Rss you didn't answer my question (im guessing you forgot)

My view's on Redknapp from what I've seen is that he's tactics are $hit, certain player's he's brought in have been $hit, the way we're playing has been $hit and some of his substations have also been $hit.

Now my question is even though ive seen a lot of games this season (tv and internet streams) am I wrong in thinking the above because I've not been to a game this season but????

[West London is Rss]

Hey Rss you didn't answer my question (im guessing you forgot)

My view's on Redknapp from what I've seen is that he's tactics are $hit, certain player's he's brought in have been $hit, the way we're playing has been $hit and some of his substations have also been $hit.

Now my question is even though ive seen a lot of games this season (tv and internet streams) am I wrong in thinking the above because I've not been to a game this season but????

Your right in thinking that and im very proud of you for thinking that.. well done.. pat on the back!

However its all well and good saying all that from reading this forum and comments from the people that have been to the away games.
So can you please back up why you think his tactics are **** from what you have seen? Why the style of play has been **** and why his subs have been ****?