What is our best starting lineup?

[knocker]

I haven't got a clue and I'm sure Harry hasn't. If we assume Charlie will be fit for Playoffs and Philips won't, what would be our best 11 to start the play offs with. Green, Simpson, barton, Morrison, austin would be a great starting point, but as for the rest, put their names in a hat and pull em out.sure hsrry does this quite often.

[MattyRangers]

For the play offs I'd like to see something like:

Green
Simpson Dunne Nedum Hill
Hoilett Barton Jenas Traore
Morrison
Austin

EDIT: Jenas in for Carroll - totally forgot about him!

[qblockoompah]

Depends who we are playing tbh.

Green
Simpson Onouha Dunne Yun
Hoilett Henry Barton Traore
Morrison
Austin

[californiahoop]

Green
Simpson hill Nedum Yun
Traore Barton Youssi hoillet
Morrison
Austin


That team wins the play off finals, if Phillips is fit, Traore swaps with Yun.

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

----------------- Green ------------------

--- Simpson ---- Dunne ---- Hill ------ BAE

-- Hoilett --- Barton --- Henry ----- SWP

----------------- Ravel ---------------------

----------------- Austin ----------------------

[knocker]

Any 4 from about 10 across the middle behind Morrison and austin. Think most would agree. Barton and then any 3 from 10 . just hope harry pulls the right ones out of the bag.

[Jogo]

----------------- Green ------------------

--- Simpson ---- Dunne ---- Onouha ------ Yun

-- Hoilett --- Barton --- Jenas ----- Traore

----------------- Ravel ---------------------

----------------- Austin ----------------------

[Norths]

If all fit then a team I would be keen to see tested would be:

Green
Simpson Ned Hill Yun
Phillips Barton Jenas Traore
Morrison
Austin

[winalotto]

If he had everyone fit and firing he would know his 11 , but its very rare you can pick the same 11 week in week out , and whats happened to us this year with injuries is unbelievable really, its ripped the heart out the side , and just when players have started to step up they get injured to..

[Nick]

Green
Simpson. Onuoha. Hill. Yun
Hoilett. Barton. Jenas. Traore
Morrison
Austin

All very well saying this but most of these players haven't been available for most of the season...

Simpson- injured
Onuoha- injured
Hoilett-injured
Jenas- injured
Traore- injured
Morrison- new
Austin- injured
and there's probably an argument for joey not being consistently available due to injury and suspension.

[knocker]

Not one vote for Kranjcar? Surely if he was anywhere near fit he would have to be considered. Send him away for 3 weeks training with the marines to loose a few pounds!!

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Not one vote for Kranjcar? Surely if he was anywhere near fit he would have to be considered. Send him away for 3 weeks training with the marines to loose a few pounds!!

Too fat.

[Brian Wilson]

Same for me. That team would win the playoff final providing Yun got game time between now and the end of season.

If all fit then a team I would be keen to see tested would be:

Green
Simpson Ned Hill Yun
Phillips Barton Jenas Traore
Morrison
Austin

[Brian Wilson]

Not one vote for Kranjcar? Surely if he was anywhere near fit he would have to be considered. Send him away for 3 weeks training with the marines to loose a few pounds!!

Too much of a luxury player. Same as Benayoun, its hard to fit them in without weakening the team overall.

[Rangers77]

For the play offs I'd like to see something like:

Green
Simpson Dunne Nedum Hill
Hoilett Barton Jenas Traore
Morrison
Austin

EDIT: Jenas in for Carroll - totally forgot about him!

Near to mine

Green
Simpson Onouha Dunne Hill
Barton Jenas
Benyaoun Morrison Holliett
Austin