Carroll

[W12_Ranger]

Such a poor player , sickening to think he was given the No.10 shirt this season. Can only pass sideways or back, can't shoot, can't tackle, can't create....wtf does he have to offer QPR? Surely we have a youth team player who deserves a chance over him? Lorded as a great passer of the ball by Redknapp, might look great in five asides in training but when it matters he simply isn't good enough.

[Ginger Ninja]

Bad game today but you clearly didnt watch the Boro or Wigan games if you dont know what he can offer.

[W12_Ranger]

Bad game today but you clearly didnt watch the Boro or Wigan games if you dont know what he can offer.

I've seen enough through the season to see he offers **** all.

Didn't see Boro was at Wigan

[Nick]

Bad game today but you clearly didnt watch the Boro or Wigan games if you dont know what he can offer.

Most people seem to put those kind of games to the back of their heads.

[West Acton]

Bad game today but you clearly didnt watch the Boro or Wigan games if you dont know what he can offer.

Got to agree with W12 here. Yes he played well against Boro and Wigan (which I praised him for) but what about the other 15 20 games where he has offered SFA

Two decent games does not camouflage or make up for the reminder of the season which has demonstrated that he is a poor poor player. Had to play today because of injuries with everyone fit he should be nowhere near the starting 11

Compare him to Henry not a world beater but gets about the pitch and does what hes on the pitch to do well so and at least offers something; Carroll offers nothing other then making the numbers up

[Rangers77]

Can rarely pass forward. Certainly can't shoot. Can anyone imagine him scoring??? I mean really imagine that???

[Timmy the Doc]

Can rarely pass forward. Certainly can't shoot. Can anyone imagine him scoring??? I mean really imagine that???

I can imagine him taking the penalty.....
and pass it to Hill.

[West Acton]

For those that always spring to his defence please explain what exactly he brings to the team

[Rangers77]

I can imagine him taking the penalty.....
and pass it to Hill.

Sideways.

[W12_Ranger]

Got to agree with W12 here. Yes he played well against Boro and Wigan (which I praised him for) but what about the other 15 20 games where he has offered SFA

Two decent games does not camouflage or make up for the reminder of the season which has demonstrated that he is a poor poor player. Had to play today because of injuries with everyone fit he should be nowhere near the starting 11

Compare him to Henry not a world beater but gets about the pitch and does what hes on the pitch to do well so and at least offers something; Carroll offers nothing other then making the numbers up

The mark of a good player in my opinion is consistency. It does not mean a footballer has to be a world beater to be consistent. Danny Simpson for instance has been a consistent player for us likewise Joey Barton this season. I never understand why people highlight one good performance out of 10. It's like when Diakite use to get slated and someone would pipe up "yeah but he played well against Arsenal"..,.

[W12_Ranger]

I can imagine him taking the penalty.....
and pass it to Hill.

Haha

[Norths]

Reverted to type then, a shame

[CroydonCaptainJack]

For those that always spring to his defence please explain what exactly he brings to the team

Go back to the other threads on the subject to see. I can't be bothered to say again as he is clearly a scapegoat.

[West Acton]

Go back to the other threads on the subject to see. I can't be bothered to say again as he is clearly a scapegoat.

Response says it all Jack. If he was worth defending you would have

Case closed

[Burnside]

His all round game is too weak. Poor mans Jimmy Smith, at least he had a few goals in his locker.