Mbia To Arsenal

[QPRDave]

Does that mean he brings out the drinks at half time? (said that before anybody else did).

knowing Mbia he'd drop them

[jmelanie]

knowing Mbia he'd drop them

And injure himself while doing so.

[Tarbie]

I do wonder about supporters like you on whether we actually watch the same matches.

This!

The only reason I can think of that anyone on here would be sad to see Mbia go is that they didn't watch too many games last season. I watched every game and the guy is poor, very poor. Mbia cannot pick a pass, he has poor control, he doesn't head the ball well, he can't beat a man, he doesn't read the game well, doesn't have a shot on him and his decision making is poor. How he has operated at the top level and commanded big transfer fees is totally beyond me as from what I saw last season he offers next to nothing at Premiership level!

[QPRDave]

This!

The only reason I can think of that anyone on here would be sad to see Mbia go is that they didn't watch too many games last season. I watched every game and the guy is poor, very poor. Mbia cannot pick a pass, he has poor control, he doesn't head the ball well, he can't beat a man, he doesn't read the game well, doesn't have a shot on him and his decision making is poor. How he has operated at the top level and commanded big transfer fees is totally beyond me as from what I saw last season he offers next to nothing at Premiership level!

But that's what i'm getting at, he'll end up at a prem club or a big euro club, so we are either not understanding the game or managers are all idiots.(In the case of Hughes that could be it)

[Dazzer1977]

As I say not played in the right position for us or with the right players around him. On what i saw last year he would b good in front of the back four which seems to be the opinion of some other well respected managers. Seems strange how so many top teams have an interest in him and he has played for some decent teams and won a few things.

I find that statement ludicrous. And now to justify, if he has bad players around him then surely it would make him look better, no? Good in front of a back 4, what like he was against Wigan when he gave that pathetic foul away with minutes on the clock, or when he made that stupid dangerous tackle on Mr Giant Forehead (aka Gervinho) at Arsenal, I can go on. The guy is more of a clown than Barton but because he gives his shirt to kids in the crowd, he's fab!

Now for his right position... We've played him in every position, apart from in goal and up front and he's still played like a clown. Constantly diving, 95% of his passing is woeful. Basically he's making, sorry, has been stealing a living from QPR, our club, for the past 12 months because he's 6ft plus who can run around for 90 mins and certainly not because he's a footballer.

One thing I do agree with you on thou is that I do too find it strange that managers from so called big clubs were chasing him (yet he signed for us). Can't think for the life of my why thou that these top managers were and given no one signed him it say it was more tabloid drivel. My views are purely based on the 33 games I attended last season both home and away, and I can't think of more than two where he played to the standard I'd expect from a Premiership but I can think of more than 15 where he was a sorry, pathetic excuse of a footballer. Athlete maybe, footballer my arris! And he's been told on twitter by me on more than 10 occasions! Another one of Hughes' pathetic crew who needs outing fast. I'd give him away with Boswinga if it was my money.

[Tarbie]

I find that statement ludicrous. And now to justify, if he has bad players around him then surely it would make him look better, no? Good in front of a back 4, what like he was against Wigan when he gave that pathetic foul away with minutes on the clock, or when he made that stupid dangerous tackle on Mr Giant Forehead (aka Gervinho) at Arsenal, I can go on. The guy is more of a clown than Barton but because he gives his shirt to kids in the crowd, he's fab!

Now for his right position... We've played him in every position, apart from in goal and up front and he's still played like a clown. Constantly diving, 95% of his passing is woeful. Basically he's making, sorry, has been stealing a living from QPR, our club, for the past 12 months because he's 6ft plus who can run around for 90 mins and certainly not because he's a footballer.

One thing I do agree with you on thou is that I do too find it strange that managers from so called big clubs were chasing him (yet he signed for us). Can't think for the life of my why. My views are purely based on the 33 games I attended last season both home and away, and I can't think of more than two where he played to the standard I'd expect from a Premiership but I can think of more than 15 where he was a sorry pathetic excuse of a footballer. Athlete maybe, footballer my arris! And he's been told on twitter by me on more than 10 occasions!

Couldn't agree more Dazzer!

[Dazzer1977]

Couldn't agree more Dazzer!

Darn it, you replied before I finished my edit!


Would you mine editing your edit to incorporate my new edit?

[zeberdee]

I find that statement ludicrous. And now to justify, if he has bad players around him then surely it would make him look better, no? Good in front of a back 4, what like he was against Wigan when he gave that pathetic foul away with minutes on the clock, or when he made that stupid dangerous tackle on Mr Giant Forehead (aka Gervinho) at Arsenal, I can go on. The guy is more of a clown than Barton but because he gives his shirt to kids in the crowd, he's fab!

Now for his right position... We've played him in every position, apart from in goal and up front and he's still played like a clown. Constantly diving, 95% of his passing is woeful. Basically he's making, sorry, has been stealing a living from QPR, our club, for the past 12 months because he's 6ft plus who can run around for 90 mins and certainly not because he's a footballer.

One thing I do agree with you on thou is that I do too find it strange that managers from so called big clubs were chasing him (yet he signed for us). Can't think for the life of my why thou that these top managers were and given no one signed him it say it was more tabloid drivel. My views are purely based on the 33 games I attended last season both home and away, and I can't think of more than two where he played to the standard I'd expect from a Premiership but I can think of more than 15 where he was a sorry, pathetic excuse of a footballer. Athlete maybe, footballer my arris! And he's been told on twitter by me on more than 10 occasions! Another one of Hughes' pathetic crew who needs outing fast. I'd give him away with Boswinga if it was my money.

Agree with all that.

[scooter lad]

IMHO, he lost interest when he realised the club was being run by mugs and blaggers. A good player if used properly

[Tarbie]

IMHO, he lost interest when he realised the club was being run by mugs and blaggers. A good player if used properly

Based on what evidence?

[scooter lad]

Based on what evidence?

On the way he played for us at first. IMO.

[Tarbie]

On the way he played for us at first. IMO.

You really think so? I watched virtually every minute he played for us last season and the only game I can remember being impressed by was the Man Utd game in November where he played at Right Back.

[Tarbie]

You really think so? I watched virtually every minute he played for us last season and the only game I can remember being impressed by was the Man Utd game in November where he played at Right Back.

......I can also remember at least 10 games where I have been left fuming at his performance!

[scooter lad]

You really think so? I watched virtually every minute he played for us last season and the only game I can remember being impressed by was the Man Utd game in November where he played at Right Back.

So not bad at rb?

[scooter lad]

......I can also remember at least 10 games where I have been left fuming at his performance!

Don't get me wrong mate, he drove me mental many times last season but like I said, think he lost interest.