Redknapp: the WATRB populus verdict

[Kevin Mcleod]

1) Not biased if one ever studied the arcane art of arithmetics: compare the sum of votes on answers 1 , 2, 3 to the number of votes on answer 4.
2) Make your own poll that would not seem biased to you, who is stopping you Here is a tip: "Do I want Harry to stay?"
1. Passionately
2. Rather, yes
3. Perhaps

Ive already done a harry in or out poll, and its biased cos you didnt out an option of 'hes doing a fine job and if he gets us up lets give him a chance in the premiership'..

[tetters]

Where's the 'best manager in the division' choice. That one.

[Olly]

Not voted, this is a very biased poll. Kirill, you should know better!!!

Option 4 doesn't need the tailing remark.
Option 5 should be 'Should see out his contract'

[supahoopsaaa]

Went for the closest option of keeping til the end of the season. No point changing now.

[Geng]

1) Not biased if one ever studied the arcane art of arithmetics: compare the sum of votes on answers 1 , 2, 3 to the number of votes on answer 4.
2) Make your own poll that would not seem biased to you, who is stopping you Here is a tip: "Do I want Harry to stay?"
1. Passionately
2. Rather, yes
3. Perhaps

the poll doesn't quite work as it your opinion on HR commits you to calling for immediate action. I think the guy is a total charlatan but I certainly don't see the point in sacking him right now.

[Geng]

I'm in the 'none of the above' camp btw. I never had any faith in HR in the first place: http://www.wearetherangersboys.com/f...e-SWP-Park-etc

Harry - the managerial equivalent of Bosingwa, Cisse, SWP, Park etc

No?

A guy with a reasonably successful career at a top club, involved in the Champions League, trophy-winner.

Drops down to little old QPR, for probably the last big contract of his career.

Who am I talking about here? The above applies to Bosingwa, SWP, Park, Cisse etc, but it also applies to Redknapp.

If we think the problem with our current squad is the amount of overpaid mercenaries, who see QPR as a last payday and, having once played at the top of the table, can no longer be arsed breaking a sweat to ensure we finish 12th rather than 18th....

...then why doesn't that same argument apply to our manager?

...so this doesn't particularly surprise me. But sacking him now would be daft. I'd like to see him go in the summer though, whatever division we're in. He's clearly not in this for anything other than the immediate short term, and I'd rather we appointed someone who wants to be at the club in five years time. I reckon he might walk anyway - would he really want to end his career with a relegation? He must know our squad would get torn to shreds in the PL. Worst case scenario is probably TF giving him 30m to spunk on his mates from Spurs class of '09, and then us getting relegated anyway.

[Kirill]

Its a harry out gang poll only thats why.

1) Not biased if one ever studied the arcane art of arithmetics: compare the sum of votes on answers 1 , 2, 3 to the number of votes on answer 4.
2) Make your own poll that would not seem biased to you, who is stopping you Here is a tip: "Do I want Harry to stay?"
1. Passionately
2. Rather, yes
3. Perhaps

[Geng]

Hilarious to see the WATRBs hive mind finally cotton on to what several of us were saying back in the Autumn. Back then, we pointed out our inability to score goals, entertain, or look like we were progressing into any sort of 'team' rather than a collection of the best paid individuals in the league. And we were shouted down by people saying "the table don't lie! we are top of the league!!! support the team and stop moaning!"

[Kevin Mcleod]

Anyone else but Redknapp would be getting pelted by now. The fact he is the media darling and supposedly a good bloke clouds the fact he is not the manager we are led to believe. Any other manager that churned out the dross he has all season long wouldhave been gone by now.

Or maybe every other fan on the planet would be happy with the manager keeping the club in the top three all season long eh.

[1973 ranger]

Anyone else but Redknapp would be getting pelted by now. The fact he is the media darling and supposedly a good bloke clouds the fact he is not the manager we are led to believe. Any other manager that churned out the dross he has all season long wouldhave been gone by now.

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

Judge him in May.

No one was ever promoted in February. Fact.

[Kevin Mcleod]

A bit of a bias poll!

Its a harry out gang poll only thats why.

[Shania]

Out!

The first female manager in English fotball is ready to step in as soon as possible.

On a more serious note; Warnock or Røsler.

[Greg1882]

None of the above
Changing now will not do us any good , but he needs to change tactics sharpish ,because we have flattered to deceive all season .

Sorry vesp I didn't mean now , I agree changing manager now would most definatly do more harm than good . I meant going forward I think we need to go down the younger route rather than re visiting old managers

[Jeems]

A bit of a bias poll!