The big Mackie Debate

[Slydo]

A lot of fans are saying they dont want him to go. I know he gives 100 percent but personally I dont think he is good enough. He may be a true pro and give it his all but if thats the argument then why not give me a game I would give 200 percent and play for a lot less, why not because I am not good enough. Plus if we do sign a few more players which is seems we might, and with the return of Zamora, will Mackie be a sub at best?

Thoughts?

[Del]

My thoughts are we probably don't need another Mackie thread going over the same discussion.....

Personally i would cash in. Great work ethic etc but very little quality.

[acricketer]

All depends on who we replace him with. I think he's well worth a squad place.

[Jack4QPR]

Make you right.

He was brilliant in that championship season (well before the injury anyway), and done pretty well in parts of last season, but if we can get the £3mil that is being rumoured for him I think it would be agreat bit of business by us.

[Norths]

My thoughts are we probably don't need another Mackie thread going over the same discussion.....

Personally i would cash in. Great work ethic etc but very little quality.

[Gtleighsr3]

we should keep him and just flood the market with endless jamie workout dvds.jamie does weights,jamie does marathon training etc.

[Del]

we should keep him and just flood the market with endless jamie workout dvds.jamie does weights,jamie does marathon training etc.

Haha....

I can see it now.... "Star jumps with Jamie"...... "Jamie Zumba challenge".....

[Gtleighsr3]

Del me and u should contact him now,we on to a winner,this time next year we will be millionaires i tell ya

[Norths]

Great idea

[Busheyboy]

[QUOTE=Slydo;1022223]A lot of fans are saying they dont want him to go. I know he gives 100 percent but personally I dont think he is good enough. He may be a true pro and give it his all but if thats the argument then why not give me a game I would give 200 percent and play for a lot less, why not because I am not good enough.
spot on

[Del]

Del me and u should contact him now,we on to a winner,this time next year we will be millionaires i tell ya

I'm in.

[essex]

I think it would be idiotic to sell him now, even coming off the bench for the rest of this season he could do a job for us. Then see where we are in the summer, few could argue about his worth in his championship, and i doubt he would lose any value in the second half of this season

[willis1980]

we should keep him and just flood the market with endless jamie workout dvds.jamie does weights,jamie does marathon training etc.

what like mr mackievator?

http://harryhealy.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/mr-motivator.jpg

[Gtleighsr3]

plymouth wanted to btring one out with him as the green god

[Rebel R's]

Iv been saying he is ****e for years,if a club offer £2-3 million we should take it and run