Jamie Mackie

[SammyKojoe]

This is why he should not start games. He was to put it kindly............Useless. Not the only one granted but question marks always exist with him in the starting line up. As Paul Merson just said "For all the good and quality players they have, they have players in the team that are nowhere near good enough to play in the Premiership every week" You Mr Mackie are one of them.

He offers nothing and looks lost. Then when he gets it is the same story of running into a blind alley/defender and losing it. He does not look dangerous or potent at all. Depsite his miss which i put down to a good save he can offer effort/goals from the bench. But that is his level and i hope Hughes can see this soon.

[Shania]

On a day like this, letīs conclude on the fact that he is a supersub.

[Stanley]

This is why he should not start games. He was to put it kindly............Useless. Not the only one granted but question marks always exist with him in the starting line up. As Paul Merson just said "For all the good and quality players they have, they have players in the team that are nowhere near good enough to play in the Premiership every week" You Mr Mackie are one of them.

He offers nothing and looks lost. Then when he gets it is the same story of running into a blind alley/defender and losing it. He does not look dangerous or potent at all. Depsite his miss which i put down to a good save he can offer effort/goals from the bench. But that is his level and i hope Hughes can see this soon.

Spot on.

The usual ineptitude from him today. I lost count of the number of times he just put his head down and ran with it before inevitably getting tackled or losing possession.

[Shania]

On a day like this, letīs conclude on the fact that he is a supersub.

[Dale]

Yep Shania, supersub needs to be his role

Mackie should not a starter for future games

[Franky Boy]

i dont think MH see's it this way, should SWP be starting or buy a new RM?

[The Godfather]

Sorry, didn't think Mackie was as bad as some of the others. Thought he caused them a few problems, particularly in the first half. At least he showed a bit of effort.

[SuperHoopNik]

Thought he had a really good first half, beating players and getting crosses into the box. Should have buried that 1 on 1 vs Vorm though.

[Franky Boy]

agree godfather, but he did start annoy me, kept doing the chop skill move and losing it, dont even get me started with anouha :@

[Grifter]

I didn't think Mackie was that bad either. He looked frustrated in the first half by lack of supply, and as a result wasn't always on the same wavelength as the rest of the side when he finally recieved the ball. Wasn't the reason we lost!

[The Godfather]

Don't get me wrong - he didn't have a 'good' game, but not sure why the OP has singled him out when there were some absolutely abysmal performances elsewhere on the pitch.

[SuperHoopNik]

Best players for us today - Top being the best.

1. Hoilett
2. Park
3. Diakite
4. Taarabt
5. Mackie
6. Onuoha
7. Fabio
8. Green
9.Cisse
10.Hill
11.Ferdinand

[Franky Boy]

Best players for us today - Top being the best.

1. Hoilett
2. Park
3. Diakite
4. Taarabt
5. Mackie
6. Onuoha
7. Fabio
8. Green
9.Cisse
10.Hill
11.Ferdinand

very good, accurate

[MaidaValeRanger]

Though Mackie was deecent

[ahR]

Best players for us today - Top being the best.

1. Hoilett
2. Park
3. Diakite
4. Taarabt
5. Mackie
6. Onuoha
7. Fabio
8. Green
9.Cisse
10.Hill
11.Ferdinand

The fact that someone has actually taken the time to even bother to rank players in descending order until we reach the bottom of the list is priceless in my book.... It's the equivalent of sticking ones hand down a blocked toilet (insert Hoilett joke in here if you can be... Aherm arsed...) and rummaging around at the bottom to dislodge the offending Richard The Third....