Once again Jamie Mackie....

[SammyKojoe]

My word. Absolutely woeful tonight. I know they all played bad but he stood out for how bad he was.

How many times did he lose the ball. Did he actually do anything in the whole 90 mins. He should never start again this season. Lord help me if anyone says he tried hard tonight to justify how bad he was.

Always a few deluded ones that defend him though so come on amuse us....

[jmelanie]

Is it me or has he not been good since he came back from his injury? Was he brought back too soon. He only played one reserve game and then came back in the team.

[Gtleighsr3]

give him a break,hes stepped up a lot in a couple of years,had a bad injury too.Hes not shirking even if his best isnt upto our own high standards.be positive.

[rangerforevereastcote]

He was very poor

Once again left young exposed by running up blind alleys and losin the ball

[Dale]

I see a glimmer for the old Mackie doing a nice dribble towards the end of the match

We know he has the skill and touch from what he done in the Championship but aint had it good this season

Should loan him out for a few months to get his sharpness back as he aint doing nothing for us

[qprjack92]

He does try but he is not good enough he just seems to run in straight line and doesn't look up always gets the ball caught up in his feet and cant control it . but i think sparky will see he is not quality enough .

[BigDanShittu]

He isn't good enough but who are you gonna replace him with? Smith is sh!t, slow and never takes on a man. At least Mackie tries to beat his man which only a few people in our team do which is shocking.

[Del]

He isn't good enough but who are you gonna replace him with? Smith is sh!t, slow and never takes on a man. At least Mackie tries to beat his man which only a few people in our team do which is shocking.

He is the modern day Ainsworth, endeavour yes, quality and end product no.

Personally i'd play SWP in his correct position every day of the week and i'd rather see Hogan on the left than Mackie, he has his knockers bu i think he's ok and retains possession a million times better than Mackie, is quick and will beat a man, plus when 1 on 1 is a decent finisher.

[rangerforevereastcote]

He is the modern day Ainsworth, endeavour yes, quality and end product no.

Personally i'd play SWP in his correct position every day of the week and i'd rather see Hogan on the left than Mackie, he has his knockers bu i think he's ok and retains possession a million times better than Mackie, is quick and will beat a man, plus when 1 on 1 is a decent finisher.

Think we got to get traore back before we can move swp over there , obv doesn't fancy hogan as hasn't used him when he could of

[Dando]

mackie is just not good enough. Does all the running thats it. Not saying we should boo him or anything,but the people who are singing "theres only one jamie mackie" are not helping the chances of him being dropped

[robbomk]

Very poor tonight, should be on the bench.

[Ric-Roc]

SWP right, Hogan left & Mackie impact sub at best.

[EYR]

Mackie is struggling,im not his biggest fan far from it but he is one of the only players who will carry the ball forward,otherwise we wont get out of our own half.

[Connell10]

lets face there are quite a few players in our team who are not prem class , im not gonna name names but we know who they are , huges knows who they are and the players know who they are! trouble is at this momment in time we aint got a lot of options so we as fans have to play our part by trying to encourage said players to play to the best of their limted ablitys! i think just booing and shouting at players offers nothing at the present time!

[WavyQPR]

Is Jamie mackie good enough for the prem?..the answer is no..but I think he can be,..the suggestion of loaning him out is a great idea...I don't ever recall a QPR player ever ever splitting our opinion like this...and that's 3 decades worth of visits! Feel free to correct me!..