A serious question....

[QPR Richard]

So what is Warnock supposed to do eh? Listen to us fans? Half of us love Mackie half of us don't. Half of us adore SWP the rest think hes average. Half of us think Taarabt is god the other half think he's a lazy nonchalant prima donna. Were all arm chair managers these days and yes we'd all do it differently somehow but Warnock has to do it his way. Everyone was happy as Larry last year when we got promotion. Warnock was the bees knees now the same guy making the same decisions doesnt know what hes doing? If he smiles and makes light of a loss to a top team he gets berated by some on here for not showing enough passion yet if he bollooox traore on the field for a stupid mistake he gets berated too. The guy cant win. Did anyone notice his passion when Howard Webb gave a decision against us today. 200% committed to the cause. Give it a rest ffs. Put any manager in charge of the limited squad we have and you're telling me they'd do a better job than what warnock has done. Thought not. Close the door behind you. Stop this stupid bickering and get behind Warnock and the team.

Oh, I see. So no criticism of the team is allowed because YOU say so. No criticism of the management is allowed because YOU say so. No criticism of the manager's awful decision to bawl out two players publicly is allowed because YOU say so.

I know, let's close the forum, sit in silence, and just let the club get on with it. People are entitled to have opinions about the club they love, and who are YOU to tell people to sit in silence, wear rose-tinted specs, and let the powers that be get on with it? If you don't like people to have opinions, what the effing hell are you doing on a football forum?

[Ric-Roc]

Beautiful Richard.

Just beautiful.

His name says it all to be fair.

[loftlag]

I spoke to 4 Man u fans on the way from the ground yesterday they said you have a good g keeper then said your number 11 is a good player
I spoke to 2 German lads this morning that came over for the match they did'nt think much of us but both said they thought Mackie was a good player

[paulmason]

Mackie is a very good player but not a right or left winger, as he cant cross for toffee. If he play's he needs to play behind the striker, or he should not play at all, as we have better players in those positions.

[loftlag]

Beautiful Richard.

Just beautiful.

His name says it all to be fair.

What does His name say then Ric ,would'nt end in the 3rd would it

[loftlag]

Mackie is a very good player but not a right or left winger, as he cant cross for toffee. If he play's he needs to play behind the striker, or he should not play at all, as we have better players in those positions.

It's a point Paul but He beat His F/back time and again yesterday His cross looked poor coz We had nobody making any effort to get into box or far post earier enough to give Him something to aim for

[Yousef]

Jeff, im glad you can see the problem with mackie, hes holding back swp by letting makie playing on thr right.

For a couple of minutes SWP went to the right in the 1st half and started to create some danger which made me think NW has finally got it right. However it didn't when he went back to the left. This gave me an impression that SWP is trying to tell NW he is better on the right.

[robith]

Mackie was giving Evra a torrid time on the right, but he's not a winger so he can't cross. Last five minutes of the first half SWP switched flanks, had a field day, we honestly looked on top and like we'd get something from the game.

Pained me to see him come back out on the left for the second half