A serious question....

[Jeffro]

Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?

- continuing to play Mackie
- continuing to play SWP out of position
- poor substitutions
- stubborn with tactics

Are we getting found out? No plan B?

Are people starting to question him?

[Gtleighsr3]

hope the owners are

[rangerforevereastcote]

Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?

- continuing to play Mackie
- continuing to play SWP out of position
- poor substitutions
- stubborn with tactics

Are we getting found out? No plan B?

Are people starting to question him?

In answer to your q

Yes
Yes and
Yes

[Mellowhoop]

Jeff, im glad you can see the problem with mackie, hes holding back swp by letting makie playing on thr right.

[stainrodisalegend]

still backing him as manager but its hard to argue with your point.

[Jeffro]

Mackie is their boy, Jones said as much. As long as he plays SWP won't on the right!

[Factamondo]

yes...........warnocks stubborness and typical yorkshire ' i know it all ' attitude will see us back in the fizzy pop league!

[Ric-Roc]

Why the f@ck would you play a RW with SWP's talent out of position to accommodate Jamie Mackie?

Awful decision.

If players were judged on effort, commitment & attitude Mackie would win the world player of the year every season but its not. At this level you need a lot more & I'm sorry but Jamie Mackie hasn't got that.

Every player in world football should have a slice of Jamie Mackie in him but you need to stand out in this division & he doesn't.

Play SWP on the right ffs!!

[stainrodisalegend]

There was one moment which encapsulated for me why mackie will never make a prem player. in fairness he had done well, cutting in from the right, then his touch was so bad he kicked it about five yards in front of him rather than dribbling with it at his feet. easy for man u to sweep up. as said before, great attitude, great strength but touch of a rapist. not good enough at this level.

[Dale]

Mackies touch is atrocious since his been back, great at running with the ball but terrible passing and shooting

Needs to work on his touch

[Factamondo]

Why the f@ck would you play a RW with SWP's talent out of position to accommodate Jamie Mackie?

Awful decision.

If players were judged on effort, commitment & attitude Mackie would win the world player of the year every season but its not. At this level you need a lot more & I'm sorry but Jamie Mackie hasn't got that.

Every player in world football should have a slice of Jamie Mackie in him but you need to stand out in this division & he doesn't.

Play SWP on the right ffs!!

[supahoopsaaa]

Totally agree. Mackie works hard but doesn't have the quality. If we're losing with Mackie in the team I'd rather we lost with Taarabt starting instead. At least he makes things happen and has quality about his play.

Like to see bothroyd - Taarabt - SWP behind hiedar on wednesday.

[QPR Richard]

Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?

- continuing to play Mackie
- continuing to play SWP out of position
- poor substitutions
- stubborn with tactics

Are we getting found out? No plan B?

Are people starting to question him?

All fair points but then many on here are insistent on Mackie being good enough to keep SWP off the right flank. NW agrees with this view.

Unless HH was injured, why take him off instead of Bothroyd? Oh yes, as people keep saying, he holds the ball up well!! As a forward, that's no effing good if you don't score goals.

I think NW can be stubborn at times. He must surely see the problems but making the necessary changes would be admitting he's got things wrong and would look bad with the players.

[BUSHRANGER1982]

Is Neil Warnock costing us points with his tactics and decision making?

- continuing to play Mackie
- continuing to play SWP out of position
- poor substitutions
- stubborn with tactics

Are we getting found out? No plan B?

Are people starting to question him?

Yes, to all.

[LoftusRoadLad]

And SWP has been better ? Even when on the right ? The balance of the whole team has been off since we won at Wolves.