Of the new players

[James1979]

who has impressed you the most?

Personally, I think (puncheon aside, as he;s not played really) they've all done very well. For me though, Traore has been the most impressive. This is partly because i knew little about him but he looks quality to me. i'm not sure what we paid for him but it looks a bargain.

[Mellowhoop]

think they have all improved us more then we think.

[paulmason]

Luke young and Traore. Ain't had players like them since Wilson and Bardsley

[BennyBoyRs]

Traore all day. All the others have impressed as well, but Traore has been a revelation. First time we've had a proper full back in years. Albeit he's looking likely to ply his trade on the wing now.

[SullivanQPR]

For me, Luke Young.

[Mellowhoop]

I got a load of gooner mates who all said he should of been kept and played as a winger... hes lightning and i dont think hes fit yet

[LoftusRoadLad]

Gotta be Joey. He has put QPR on the big stage with his amazing character and (getting better) football skills. He is like marmite...love him or hate him.

[DelTrotter]

Traore or Ferdinand

[Rich]

They have all added quality no doubt. This would be my summary.

Barton - My favorite of the new signings if played in CM. He adds steel, workrate and knows how to get under oppositions skin

SWP - Great to have, quick,skillful etc but his end product isn't the best imo

Ferdinand - Has the occasional concentration & positional lapse but is by far the best CB we have. His distribution is decent, he is fairly quick & works hard

Young - Has lots of knowhow and is defensively sound against most. Lacks a bit of pace though

Traore - worries me a little defensively when the ball is played in the air in his direction but has so much going forward

Bothroyd - I like Jay but he is similar to HH and imo we can only play with one of them in the starting 11.

[James1979]

Traore all day. All the others have impressed as well, but Traore has been a revelation. First time we've had a proper full back in years. Albeit he's looking likely to ply his trade on the wing now.

I'd like us to stick with him at full back though. He can still bomb down the wing. Warnock and co just need to improve him defensively. Some of the comments from fans (not qpr I might add) about how we'd bought a muppet based on the man u result. If paolo maldini in his prime had arshavin helping out in front of him, he'd have struggled in that game.

[James1979]

They have all added quality no doubt. This would be my summary.

Barton - My favorite of the new signings if played in CM. He adds steel, workrate and knows how to get under oppositions skin

SWP - Great to have, quick,skillful etc but his end product isn't the best imo

Ferdinand - Has the occasional concentration & positional lapse but is by far the best CB we have. His distribution is decent, he is fairly quick & works hard

Young - Has lots of knowhow and is defensively sound against most. Lacks a bit of pace though

Traore - worries me a little defensively when the ball is played in the air in his direction but has so much going forward

Bothroyd - I like Jay but he is similar to HH and imo we can only play with one of them in the starting 11.

barton has been a different player almost in the middle. Faurlin's game has risen at the same time, no coincidence in my opinion.

[BennyBoyRs]

I think Barton playing CM has had the biggest impact, not solely on his performances, but also for how much Ali has improved.

[robbomk]

Luke Young, although I'm really starting to appreciate Joey now. I have to admit I didn't rate him at first.

[rangerforevereastcote]

Diff ways of looking at it

Young been most consistent from
Day 1 has made very few mistakes , unbelievable fitness, mr consistent

Barton not a fan at the start but since gone in middle superb

Swp started great not been the best last few games feel a lot more to come yet (I hopeŁ

Traore been superb if a little soft and at times lazy but innterms of natural
Talent and pace incredible

Ferdinand was superb , couple of errors recently but overall superb

Gabidon mixed start for him

Jay getting better with someone with him up
There looks dangerous

No doubting as a group would suggest has been an

[rangerforevereastcote]

To finish off above ( Stupid iphone)
No Doubt a great bit of business by warnock

Think in terms of most cOnsistent since arrival

Young for me