The Mackie discussion /merged/

[rangerforevereastcote]

Faurlin had several goes at mackie today to stay in his position he kept exposing hill mackie didn't react well to being told

How he's in before swp I will never know

[Ric-Roc]

Very very very limited footballer. But he runs a lot & is a nice guy & has got a good attitude so on that basis alone he deserves every single week in the Premier League.







Unbelievable. Hope we bring in quality to dislodge him. Again I'm sorry lovely guy but you need a hell of a lot more in this division to compete & on that basis he falls short big time.

[SammyKojoe]

Faurlin had several goes at mackie today to stay in his position he kept exposing hill mackie didn't react well to being told

How he's in before swp I will never know

Ginger Ninja ( who i am sure is his Dad ) Matty Rangers and a few others that defend Mackie should answer that. They would have Mackie in above SWP every game. They love the fact he runs a lot. Am sure they must have tickets to the Olympics in the summer.

Simple fact is SWP has ability and quality at this level. Myself, Benny and a few others have been pleading for him to play on the right and lo and behold he has a blinder when played in his correct position.

Mackie looks out of his depth and offers nothing. He just does not have the ability. He should be nowhere near that starting line up.

[pauldrayton]

Agreed re: Mackie and HH. Great pros, good Championship players but not Premier League standard unfortunately.

[MattyRangers]

Mackie and HH are not good enough at this level.

Derry and Hill just about get away with it.

HH not good enough? Words defy me. Some people are totally clueless.

[SammyKojoe]

Helguson not good enough? Guy has been excellent this season.

Mackie on the other hand is toilet.

[Dale]

Mackie on the wing totally lost again

NW needs to stop playing him as we are suffering with him on the wing doing nothing

Need to stop this madness of playing him every game

[stainrodisalegend]

Fed up with a player who is toilet - we want Hoilet...

[Dale]

If we got Hoilet he would just sit on the bench like swp as NW would not pick them over Golden boy Mackie

[w12dave]

it a joke but nw is making me hate the fella now and it not even his fault he is not good enough to play for Qpr.

Stop it Neil!

[stainrodisalegend]

0-0 though - that wd spell replay and take up one of Barton's banned games.

[Dando]

i cant even be bothered to debate about Mackie anymore. Hes notgood enough, end of! i would have him as impact sub at the most. How Warnock cant see this is beyond me

[OldSchool]

I think envy one can see the limitations of Mackie apart from Warnock! This along with persisting with formations that do not work, mind boggling substitutions and, especially, choosing to defend, rather than attack, against a NINE man Chelsea, have made me lose faith in Warnock this season!

[Connell10]

I despair at warnocks love fest with mackie! Play swp for focks sake and drop mackie!

[Gtleighsr3]

mackies got some guns going on,perhaps neil likes seeing him pump them in his tight shirt down the wing.